Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
August 5, 2011
The Absurdity Of Repression In …?

Professor As'ad AbuKhalil, aka the Angry Arab, writes:

arresting boys and girls in Tehran

Look at this example of the absurdity of repression in Iran:  "In the 40C heat of an Iranian summer, what better way to have fun and stay cool than a water fight with friends? In the Islamic republic, however, things are a bit more complicated.  For one group of boys and girls, their game turned serious when they were arrested for taking part in a water pistol fight in a park in the capital, Tehran."

The absurdity of repression. Indeed:

Wandsworth Council said organisers were inviting people through Facebook to participate in the event in late July.

Police officers with dogs will patrol the park entrances and stop suspects, who could face up to a £200 fine.

The warning comes after a similarly organised water fight in Hyde Park resulted in disorder and arrests.

Three people were arrested after some 1,500 people got involved in the water fight on 4 June, which continued for eight hours and resulted in the closure of Oxford Street to traffic.

Why do I fail to find any criticism at the Angry Arab site of the water pistol fight arrests and the absurdity of repression in the United Kingdom?

Comments

Those of us in the “enlightened, democratic West” are just supposed to be so grateful for all the rights and freedoms we have that we dasn’t say anything if they’re…well, impeded, taken away, stepped on….

Posted by: jawbone | Aug 5 2011 22:43 utc | 1

re: “Why do I fail to find any criticism at the Angry Arab site of the water pistol fight arrests and the absurdity of repression in the United Kingdom?”
Probably due to unawareness and the general triviality and lack of importance of the UK. In contrast, the Angry Arab often critiques such comparative hypocrisy in the USA.
If Americans begin protesting to the same degree as the Iranians (eg, the Iranian election protests) then we’ll probably see a far more brutal crackdown here.

Posted by: mussogorski | Aug 6 2011 2:14 utc | 2

Tracing the article back through the Angry Arab to the Guardian article which inspired it, it becomes apparent that the arrests had nothing to do with water pistols or water fights. The arrests took place after the event and arose from perceived transgressions of Islamic laws concerning public decency in a gathering with male and female participants.
I haven’t ‘followed’ the Angry Arab website but have read several A-A articles linked from elsewhere. On the few occasions I’ve skimmed the site after reading a linked article I never bothered bookmarking it due to the mixed messages I found there. I prefer sites with more ‘ideological purity’ than I found at A-A.

Posted by: Hoarsewhisperer | Aug 6 2011 3:34 utc | 3

In fairness, I think the Angry Arab would criticize the arrests in Hyde Park, if he knew about them or cared about events in the UK.
The Angry Arab is lavish in his disdain both for Arab governments and for their Saudi, Israeli and Western patrons. Given the long list of daily outrages perpetrated by the above, it would take a superhuman effort to catalog all the abuses everywhere.

Posted by: JohnH | Aug 6 2011 4:44 utc | 4

I follow AngryArab and he uses to criticize the hypocrisy of western democracies and media on religious matters when something is reported as very negative or backwards when the religion is Islam and gets ignored or not reported in a negative way when it’s Christian or Jewish. For example he also uses to frequently mock about the ‘throwing shoes is an Arab insult’ meme as it wasn’t in any other culture.
However as a radical secular and feminist leftist he obviously doesn’t support the regimes of Syria, Iran, Libya, or Hizbollah as a religious group rather than an anti-Israeli resistance group, and regularly attacks them for their backwardness and repression. You can disagree with a single report taken out of context or with his whole ideology but in that he is clearly quite consistent and much more than any mainstream reporter or blogger. He mock any western country if a similar event was repressed for pious reasons, just send him a mail so he can notice the event.

Posted by: ThePaper | Aug 6 2011 7:40 utc | 5

AngryArab, what crap this man is a typical middle class American Professor might probably be an agency as**! How come he is still surviving in the academical world with criticism about Zionism, Saudi’s , go figure!

Posted by: hans | Aug 6 2011 8:47 utc | 6

Angry Arab frequently mocks the racist hypocrisy of singling out for criticism Muslims or Arabs for things that also happen in non-Muslim countries. This is one of his strengths. You must not be reading him regularly.

Posted by: Xihuitl | Aug 6 2011 9:19 utc | 7

Angry Arab frequently mocks the racist hypocrisy of singling out for criticism Muslims or Arabs for things that also happen in non-Muslim countries. This is one of his strengths.
In this case it is Angry Arab singling out Muslims for things that also happen in non-Muslim countries. That was my point.
Just shows that he is as much a hypocrite as those he frequently mocks.

Posted by: b | Aug 6 2011 10:07 utc | 8

Just shows that he is as much a hypocrite as those he frequently mocks.

Thanks b, this is exactly what I was struggling to say in English. Great minds think alike and all that!

Posted by: hans | Aug 6 2011 10:36 utc | 9

actually b. I think angry arab is right, there is repression in Iran. that fact does not change by repression being in other places, too.
and there is a difference in conflict resolution in Britain and let’s say Syria
– though events are similar
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-14435251
though it has to be mentioned as an excuse for Syria, that no outside powers supply Tottenham with weapons

Posted by: somebody | Aug 7 2011 8:57 utc | 10

Accusations of licentious, obscene, depraved, corrupting of morals, creating disorder, either in representation (pictures, text, etc.) or in behavior….have been a mainstay of all the powerful always, as such accusations and control cut to the heart of whatever social organization exists, and how to uphold it, by appealing to conservative elements, who are more inclined to bow to authority (or hope to participate in it) and thus agree to or endorse repressive measures, which then serve the PTB for other matters.
One ex. which I have just been reading about, which may seem a little off topic but is connected…In 1971 a famous case in England took place: the Oz magazine published amongst others a picture of Rupert the Bear (a character for children) with a huge erection. It seems quaint today when ten year olds eat ice cream while secretly watching porn…Anyway the Old Bailey was busy for 6 weeks or so with this matter, very interesting. Clearly the establishment was spooked – what next? At the time the porn industry was run in part by the Police and attacking underground or alternative mags provided cover.
The old colonialists used to be horrified at the unbridled dress, sexual manners, public behavior, etc. of the poor people they exploited and controlled, and clamped down, hard. But now, after the so called sexual revolution and under the ‘freedom ticket’, conservatism in such matters has become a stigma, a mark a people gripped in the dark ages, outdated customs, rabid religion, patriarchy, tribalism, etc. hypocritically condemned by the stooge left- Democrats and their ilk. (Israel as a target is exempt of course.)
Water fights are fun, disruptive, sexy …. all over the world… what next? but in the West they, and other such large gatherings, are not repressed because of ‘sex’ or ‘personal morals’ – the mingling of boys and girls with now transparent clothes – but because some kind of collective forms and it occupies public space, takes it over, shows off, stakes a claim.
As the reasons for the repression are *ostensibly* different, it is perhaps comprehensible that the Angry Arab, if he even knew about events in GB, would not relate the two. His mission is bashing Israel and the ArabWorld, in part on the personal identity-cultural-moral sexual behavior etc. issues.

Posted by: Noirette | Aug 8 2011 14:11 utc | 11

Police reassure residents they are working to keep county safe

Temporary Assistant Chief Constable Maurice Mason has reassured residents in Essex that police are working to keep the county safe.

A 20-year-old man from Colchester who allegedly sent messages from a Blackberry encouraging people to join in a water fight has been charged with encouraging or assisting in the commission of an indictable only offence under the Serious Crime Act 2007. He has been conditionally bailed to appear at Colchester Magistrates’ Court on September 1.

Posted by: b | Aug 16 2011 4:15 utc | 12