Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
January 31, 2011
John Barry’s Historical Revisionism

Writing in Newsweek John Barry uses historical revisionism to let Hillary Clinton look good:

As Secretary of State Hillary Clinton herself put it last month, in a speech in Doha that now seems uncannily prescient, Arab leaders would face growing unrest, extremism, and even rebellion unless they reformed “corrupt institutions and a stagnant political order.” It was the starkest warning ever delivered by a senior American official, and a message brought home a few days later when Tunisia erupted in revolt.

Clinton held her speech in Doha on January 13. The very same day Reuters wrote:

Tunisian President Zine al-Abidine Ben Ali, facing the worst unrest of his rule, said on Thursday he would not run again when his term ends in 2014, prompting scenes of celebration in the streets of the capital.

Ben Ali, only the second head of state Tunisia has ever had and in office for over 23 years, set his departure date in an emotional televised speech made after weeks of deadly clashes between protesters and police.

The speech Clinton held did not show "uncannily prescient" remarkable foresight, as Barry wants to make his readers believe, but was a quite late reaction nearly a month after Tunisia started to erupted in revolt.

Such overt bootlicking may buy the author more access to Clinton and other officials, but it is a disservice to his readers.

Comments

good catch

Posted by: annie | Jan 31 2011 17:06 utc | 1