Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
December 17, 2010
Afghanistan – U.S. Concern About China Hinders Political Solution

For the "western" troops to leave Afghanistan without letting it continue to fall deeper into its the civil war a political solution will be required. Such a solution will have to include a government participation for the Taliban.

Washington is not yet willing to allow that. That has nothing to do with some moral question or women rights. Washington has lots of friends and allies who behave much worse then the Taliban ever did. The real issue is a, largely imagined, U.S. conflict with China.

To negotiate seriously with the Taliban an agreement will have to be found with the Pakistani military which at least partly controls that movement.

The concern of the Pakistani military is an Afghanistan under heavy Indian influence and, resulting from that, a potential two front war. The concern is not without merit. Karzai was educated in India and India has same para-militaries, an embassy and four consular offices in Afghanistan which certainly do not have the sole purpose of stamping visa into passports.

For Pakistan to agree to further serious negotiations with the Taliban, at least a temporary solution has to be found to alleviate its fears with regard to India.

The way to fundamentally relieve Pakistani fear of India is to find a solution for Kashmir. While the Kashmir conflict is partly a Hindu versus Muslim religious conflict and partly an ethnic/tribal conflict the real Kashmir concern for Pakistan are the water sources from the Himalaya that spring up in Kashmir and feed the Indus river. The Indus is literally the lifeline that feeds Pakistan's people. Uncontested Indian rule in Kashmir with the ability to cut off Pakistan's water is a knife to its throat.

A solution for Kashmir could be some vote for independence by the people living there, as promised to them a long time ago but never allowed, followed by a neutrality and water sharing agreement with its neighbors.

To at least temporarily have the Pakistani agree on a negotiated solution for Afghanistan, India (and Karzai) will have to leave Afghanistan. The U.S. would have to press India for this to happen.

But the U.S. does not want to pressure India on anything, not even on leaving Afghanistan. It is fantasizing about a big conflict with China in which, it assumes, India will be an ally.

So for now the U.S. will continue to pay a $120 billion per year in Afghanistan to achieve nothing. A few years down the road and after some more serious budget pressure Congress will finally have enough of it. The U.S. will then leave without a political solution. The civil war in Afghanistan will continue and a few years later the Taliban will have again won.

That is not the necessary outcome, but it is what the current purely military U.S. policy, if continued, will achieve.

Recommended readings:
How the Afghan Counterinsurgency Threatens Pakistan – Anatol Lieven/The Nation
The Way Out of Afghanistan – Ahmed Rashid/NYRB
In deadly Kandahar, skepticism over gains cited in Afghan war review – CSM
Fresh Approach: It’s Time for the Afghans to Leave Afghanistan – World Affairs

Comments

WikiLeaks cables from india on the issue:
US embassy cables: Indian fears over reconciliation efforts in Afghanistan

He warned the USG not to be drawn into what he characterized as a Pakistani “game” of enlisting American support to “drive India out of Afghanistan” by presenting “fabricated” evidence of alleged Indian misdeeds in Afghanistan or the border areas. Sinha praised the Secretary’s interventions regarding assistance to Afghan women during the January London Conference on Afghanistan, but expressed skepticism over reintegration/reconciliation efforts …

US embassy cables: Indian officials deliver bleak vision of longterm relations with Pakistan

Y.K.Sinha lamented that recent media focus on the corruption and inefficiency of Afghan President Hamid Karzai’s government is “undermining” international community efforts in Afghanistan. Sinha, who is the functional equivalent of an Assistant Secretary and the GOI’s senior point person on Af-Pak policy, stated that the GOI avoids “micromanaging” its dealings with Karzai but stresses instead the importance of keeping Taliban elements and Islamists out of the government.

US embassy cables: Red Cross clashes with India over treatment of detainees

In a April 1 confidential briefing on GOI detention centers in Kashmir, ICRC XXXXXXXXXXXX described to D/Polcouns torture methods and relatively stable trend lines of prisoner abuses by Indian security forces, based on data derived from 1491 interviews with detainees during 2002-2004.

Posted by: b | Dec 17 2010 17:36 utc | 1

The Daily Telegraph reports that Turkish-led secret talks are underway in order to reduce Iran’s stockpile of enriched uranium.
http://www.haaretz.com/news/international/report-in-effort-to-end-sanctions-iran-negotiating-nuclear-swap-1.331211
but then
U.S., EU Nations Agree on New Iran Sanctions
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748703395904576025981950455382.
Noteworthy that the telegraph, Jerusalem Post and Haaretz were some of the very first to report on the “secret” deal story.

Posted by: Anthony | Dec 17 2010 23:09 utc | 2

Great post; great links.
I am so very happy to see you writing again. I hope you have been well.
Warmest Regards, Joseph

Posted by: Joseph | Dec 17 2010 23:51 utc | 3

Tim Geithner in China Getting laughed at by Chinese Students
meanwhile, snitch nation; FBI Agents Train Garbage Collectors To Report Suspicious Activity

Posted by: Uncle $cam | Dec 18 2010 23:08 utc | 4