Chris Floyd linked and quoted my piece on Obama Implements Neocon Startegy Against Iran. Thanks Chris!
He received some comments towards his piece.
The first one must have been a bit weird with comments copied from here included and Chris deleted that one it was down-voted into the nirvana.*
Then another of his commentators by the name blue ox babe refers to that and presents his/her view of the commentators at this site:
the gang at Moon of Alabama are moderately arrogant, and highly partisan. they are the sort to think of “practical” solutions which involve murdering other nations’ innocents if the “national security” interests are valuable enough to the MoA commenter in question. what MoA is, essentially, is a bunch of wannabe policy wonks.
Now you know it!
This blog received 123.697 comments as of now. Can someone please show me the one where the author seems ‘to think of “practical” solutions which involve murdering other nations’ innocents if the “national security” interests are valuable enough‘ ? I must have missed that one.
Funny that blue ox babe later admits that he/she comments here him/herself under a different moniker. His/her statement above was self referential?
A comment further at Chris’ site commentator wal, the one who posted the first – now deleted – comment there, asserts:
… this discussion was the subject of two posts at MoA the first of which was originally titled Obama Attempts to Blackmail Russia.which was renamed Obama Continues Bush’s Russia Policy after it was thoroughly discredited by clever commenters who researched and dissected the issue.
Hmm – I admit that I sometimes change the headlines of my posts. Usually within a the first few minutes after publishing and rereading them live. But I never changed a headline because of the comments the post received.
I did not do so with the Russia post. I did not ‘rename‘ it and I can prove that.
The system this blog runs on is Typepad and it has a specific way to assign URL’s to a new post. The first part of the URL is always “http://www.moonofalabama.org” followed by “/year/month” and then by “/pagename.html”
When I save a draft post before assigning the headline then the first words of the post are used as the pagename. See this one for an example.
When I assign a headline before saving the post the headline becomes the pagename. For example: The post James Baker On Solving The Crisis has the pagename “/james-baker-on-solving-the-crisis.html”. The headline was assigned before saving and publishing the post.
When a headline is later changed and the piece saved and published again the system does not generate a new pagename but the old pagename is kept. I have no way to influence that. For example: The post Britain Will Lose The Afghan Drugwar has the pagename: “/britains-afghan-drugwar-will-be-lost-.html”. Obviously I change the headline of that post after saving it first under a different headline.
Now onto the Russia post. Did I change the headline because the comments were going in this or that direction?
The headline is Obama Continues Bush’s Russia Policy and the pagename is “/obama-continues-bushs-russia-policy.html”. Hmm – seems to me the post still has its original headline.
What does that tell us about wal’s accuracy in commenting?
—
*Changed after Chris rightly corrected me.