Yves Smith has some good remarks on how Finance Has Lost Sight of Its Role
In 1980, financial firms accounted for 8% of S&P earnings. During the peak of our last stock market cycle, their profits were over 40% of the total.
Now consider: finance is a necessary function, but is represents a tax, a drain on the productive economy, just as defense and lawyers do …
Instead being a utility that supports the real productive industry, the financial industry has turned into a cult.
Willem Buiter has chastised the Fed for what he calls "cognitive regulatory capture," that is, that they identify far too strongly with the values and world view of their charges. But it isn’t just the Fed. The media. and to a lesser degree, society at large has bought into the construct of the importance, value, and virtue of the financial sector, even as it is coming violently apart before our eyes. Why, for instance, the vituperative reaction against a GM bailout, while we assume Citi has to be rescued?
Why indeed? Why this?
The U.S. government is prepared to lend more than $7.4 trillion on behalf of American taxpayers, or half the value of everything produced in the nation last year, to rescue the financial system since the credit markets seized up 15 months ago.
As I wrote last month:
Where is the social benefit?
Can we please have a plan for a financial system that is a service to the economy and not a drag – not a monster that depends on over-leveraged quant strategies nobody really understands?
While now bank after bank gets nationalized, possibly all of them within the next 12 month, we get the once in a lifetime chance to cut the financial system back to the boring utility service that it should be: Collecting savings and distributing them as loans for productive means while maybe making a small profit.
That is the only social and economic value the financial industry has. Everything else is obfuscation of robbery driven by greed.