Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
November 14, 2008
Rahm Emanuel (Re-)Engaged

On November 6 this blog picked up echos from Israeli media about Rahm Emanuel as Obama’s Chief of Staff. One was from the Jerusalem Post and it included this:

In an interview with Ma’ariv, Emanuel’s father, Dr. Benjamin Emanuel, said he was convinced that his son’s appointment would be good for Israel. "Obviously he will influence the president to be pro-Israel," he was quoted as saying. "Why wouldn’t he be? What is he, an Arab? He’s not going to clean the floors of the White House."

The next day Helena Cobban took that up and wrote a (re-)engaged piece: R. Emanuel: Repudiate this disgusting racist comment.

The Jewish Telegraphic Agency reported the remarks in a longer Emanuel piece on November 9.

By the time JTA reached the elder Emanuel, a physician, it was clear his son had asked him to keep away from reporters. Picking up the phone, he said, "This is Benjamin Emanuel, the plumber," and asked a reporter to call back in a week, after he’d spoken in person to Rahm – "if I’m still alive then."

On November 11 the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee wrote (pdf) to Congressman Emanuel and cc’ed Obama:

The American‐Arab Anti‐Discrimination Committee (ADC) views this characterization of an Arab as an unacceptable smear. One can readily imagine the justifiable outcry if someone made a similar remark about African‐Americans, Jews, or Hispanics, concerning cleaning the floors of the White House. Do the normal standards of decency and civility not apply when talking about Arabs? ADC asks you to disavow and repudiate these remarks publicly.

Yesterday Emanuel phoned up the ADC President and fomer Rep. (D-Ohio) Mary Rose Oakar and declared:

From the fullness of my heart, I personally apologize on behalf of my family and me. These are not the values upon which I was raised or those of my family.

We are left to wonder on who’s values, if not his father’s, Rahm Emanuel was raised and why he marks his father as someone outside of his family.


Voluntary advertisement:

Buy Re-Engage! American and the World after Bush; An Informed Citizen’s Guide by Helena Cobban

Comments

[b- the final link is broken]

Posted by: b real | Nov 14 2008 19:01 utc | 1

@b real – thx – fixed

Posted by: b | Nov 14 2008 19:06 utc | 2

straws for bloggers to chase the wind
Rahm Emanuel is one powerful piece in the Dem Machine, care about poor ppl, gtfa, here’s chaf …………….

Posted by: CP | Nov 14 2008 19:40 utc | 3

On the other side of the fence they
re thinking this.

Posted by: anna missed | Nov 14 2008 20:07 utc | 4

anna missed , speaking of that handshake..Thousands gather in Israel to mark Rabin killing

more than 100,000 attended the gathering.
The rally opened with film footage of Rabin addressing the 1995 rally, thanking participants for coming out to support the theme: “No to violence, yes to peace.” Facing the large crowd from the same balcony where Rabin spoke 13 years ago, Israeli singers sang.
Rabin’s government negotiated the first interim peace accord with the Palestinians, and he won a Nobel Peace Prize for his efforts. His successor as leader of the Labor party, Defense Minister Ehud Barak, promised to continue in his path.
We have no other country and we have no other way. There is no alternative to peace,” he said.

Teamsters Union President James P. Hoffa, on his first visit to Israel, said he brought greetings from President-elect Obama, whom he called “a true friend and partner of Israel.” One message in the crowd read: “Obama, make peace now!”
Hoffa, a strong Obama supporter, ended his words by riling the crowd into chanting Obama’s campaign slogan: “Yes We Can.”

praying for the peace movement in israel.

Posted by: annie | Nov 14 2008 20:27 utc | 5

@CP – straws for bloggers to chase the wind … care about poor ppl, gtfa, here’s chaf
Why is there no link to your program or your blog on helping poor ppl in your comment?

Posted by: b | Nov 14 2008 20:32 utc | 6

I can think of no correlation between the belief systems of the parents, and the belief systems of their children, in America. My mother was a John Birch racist,
and I married a brown skin. My father was a Reagan militarist, and I was a C.O.
Paris Hilton just like her mother? Yeah. Hank Paulson just like his father? Absurd.
Then b’s comments smearing Emanuael, are just as egregious as those of his father,
and Emanuel’s apology all that much more dear, considering the antiHebrew rabble.
Like Malooga, prognosticators at MoA need to drink from the Xanax well for awhile.
Emanuel’s middle-of-the-road record is certainly better than Bush’s Chief of Staff.

Posted by: Peris Troika | Nov 14 2008 21:16 utc | 7

middle of the road
you can’t be serious Peris.
anyone who leads the congress to take away my 4th Amendment rights is not middle of the road. he is my enemy. supposedly we in the military (I am retired now) had been fighting all these years to preserve freedom and then a bunch of panty waisted congresscritters and senators can snatch it away to satisfy the boy king. and I need to chill out?
Emanuael bought his position in the Obama administration. He gets to filter information going to and coming from the president. that is massive power and not a single one of us voted for him.
no sir, he needs to be under a very strong magnifying glass and every pimple and wart needs to be seen clearly. it is not enough to be not as bad as the other side.
/rant

Posted by: dan of steele | Nov 14 2008 21:45 utc | 8

I can think of no correlation between the belief systems of the parents, and the belief systems of their children, in America.
america is no different than any place else in the world. anyone who doesn’t understand how a child’s morals or belief systems are correlated to their upbringing has rocks for brains.
that said, no..it doesn’t mean they are passed on like dna. that wasn’t b’s point tho. i am not a fan of emanuel, and the wording of his apology was disingenuous but none the less, it was an apology and a refutation of his father’s sentiments and for that i applaud him.
we all know we aren’t going to get everything we want from this administration wrt israel/palestine. i still hold out hope we get something and some progress. whether emanuel can be of service in this regard has yet to be seen. maybe it is better than having cantor in there or some other rabid neocon.
he needs to be under a very strong magnifying glass and every pimple and wart needs to be seen clearly. it is not enough to be not as bad as the other side.
i totally agree.

Posted by: annie | Nov 14 2008 22:30 utc | 9

“Obama’s Victory – Fear and Hope”
only fear makes sense, hope has no substance

Posted by: constant | Nov 15 2008 0:04 utc | 10

only fear makes sense
how about constant fear constant. does that have substance?

Posted by: annie | Nov 15 2008 0:22 utc | 11

Annie, Comment text is required. Do you know me?

Posted by: constant | Nov 15 2008 0:58 utc | 12

fear is one of the senses (to me), a part of preception, which makes you aware. nature shows the way. how you react to it is personal.
reality is harsh, sweet etc. and as far as I know needs no hope to get by.

Posted by: constant | Nov 15 2008 1:14 utc | 13

Hey, thanks for the bouquet and the free plug for my book, B!

Posted by: Helena Cobban | Nov 15 2008 2:48 utc | 14

i loathe with all my heart, anti-semitism especially instinctive antisemitism because it does represent the darker impulses of anhilation in western civilisation. the germans did not invent it – they just synthesised & acted upon it on an industrial scale
& this anhilatory impulse is at the very heart of western civilisation as walte benjamin repeatedly warned us
the indigenous people of the world have been massacred for centuries without a thought for their humanity. not one single thought. & the false efforts of reconciliation given the circumstances are absolutely cruel & obscene
when moa began b real led me to read again & again the works on what the empire did to north american indians – that history simply cannot be read without fury & tears. of the nobility, of the natural nobility of the oppressed & of the casual violence used for centuries against them & whether it is sweden or australia – the history of the indigenous people is a history written in blood that can never be cleaned by tears
saying that, when i heard the comment by emannuel sr – & it is widely held in israel’s leading circles – that arabs are worth less than nothing – i feel the same fury – the same hate. arabophobia fills the stinking sewer of contemporary communication & sadly it is all too evident in france where there has always been a reprochement between the two people’s
what is happening in gaza is tearing me apart & no one who knows any history of the jewish people can ignore the historical precedents of the collective punishment & targeted assassinations (murder by any name) . civilisation is watching a people being extinguished & we know everything, we know in detail & we even know of the plans of zionist thugs of the likud who want a final solution to the palestinian problem – whether they call it the jordan option or something softer – it is nothing other than the aneantisment of a people reproducing exactly the same methods that were used aginst the jewish people of europe less than a century ago. it is shameful, it is repulsive, it is a crime
& whoever legitimises that crime is my enemy
fear – the constant tool that is used against these people forgets – that it was the arabs that gave birth to the very fucking civilisation – in medicine, maths, astronomy, in all the sciences – the alphabet – the real beginning of philosophy as something other than spurius metaphysics. whatever erudition western civilisation possesses it is in the greatest debt to the arab & persian people
they are our cradle & it is they who have sung the sweetest songs
& those who forget that are complicit in a crime
i have great difficulty with monetheism of any kind. i am a communist, after all but there used to be in islam especially its more speculative sufi aspect – something close to surrender which is qualitatively different from the submission that both christianity & judaism have too often required instead of faith. & i think it is we who have helped turn that religion into a hammer more closely resembling the thuggery of oral roberts or rebbe kehane
then that is no mystery – the leading theologians who have influenced political islam – were without exception borne in the prisons of tyrannies that the british, french & u s empire willingly assisted understanding perfectly what was happening – the leading thinker sayyid qutb, often called the father of al quaeda – went from a genuine & exploratory theology into a harder & harder stone with each incarceration, with each torture – the passions of that man’s body were not so different from the stories they tell us of christ
in paul celans great poem, he sd the death was german. today, it is clear for the arab peopled, death is an american

Posted by: remembereringgiap | Nov 15 2008 3:28 utc | 15

remembereringgiap, very well said…

Posted by: vbo | Nov 15 2008 4:45 utc | 16

Thanks again r’giap.
It is an irony that I, a conservative in method, a non-socialist in liberty, and a disciple of Jesus in religious view, value your posts so much. Each of your posts reveals a true caring for our neighbors, and a goal for social justice that I admire and learn from. Normally I would criticize profanity/vulgarity, but in your posts, it clearly adds to your passion for caring. I have a post written that I am not posting on the Open Thread out of respect for your latest post there. Quite plainly, it would be an embarrassment to post the near meaningless crap I just wrote next to your good work. Maybe b can start a new Open Thread to preserve your thoughts as an end reflection.

Posted by: Rick | Nov 15 2008 6:29 utc | 17

‘giap @15–straight through tendon and ligaments, hitting bone, you condense the little genocides and casual stompings of empire into pellets hard enough for planting, but soft enough to grow.
the stewards of death aren’t happy when we sing, or even comfortable encouraging any curiosity about the past.
maybe latin america will be able to forgive the north if the crimes of empire are ever honestly acknowledged by the dollar zombies careening across pavement in the eventual hearses of their short-sighted gratification.

Posted by: Lizard | Nov 15 2008 6:38 utc | 18

Some seem to be saying with hope in their hearts that nominating Emanuel is a way of neutralizing him – you have to do something with the powerful members of your club, canalize, occupy them. I don’t see it that way at all – completely independently of the Israel thorn – the proposed policies of Emanuel and Obama have been similar or roughly identical for many years (see my previous posts) and how that came about, who copied or scoped out whom, who relied on whom, or whatnot, or how these great independent (err..) minds met and joined up is opaque.
Oh the ‘some’ I read is surprisingly Xymphora, who *used* to be interesting sort of conspiracy-kinda blogger (he was very good on 9/11 for a long time), but who has in recent times turned quote anti-semitic unquote, the precise brand I can’t describe. link
Which reminds me of a link I wanted to post, about the dangers of anti-semitism (in the sense of despising Jews); anti-Muslim or anti-Arab sentiments are stronger, in their public expression, today, as they are permitted, considered legitimate, even encouraged. (Europe.) Pew

Posted by: Tangerine | Nov 15 2008 13:23 utc | 19

hey, I don’t know what $%^T you’re stirring up somewhere b, but this might make you go hmmmm….
Wikipedia deletes Benjamin Emanuel entry
And if you actually read the deleted page log, the reasons are all over the place and certainly not addressing why there should NOT be a page.
Me, it doesn’t matter if that man was/is racist; if he said it, and happens to get into the news because of it, wikipedia better track it, rather than deleting it.
Stupid guys, don’t realise that this %^&t is all over the place and it makes them fit into stereotypes.

Posted by: shanks | Nov 15 2008 14:18 utc | 20

Tangerine @19
Xymphora is more “strong dislike” rather than anti-semitism. Sure, he’s got a number of C’theories with him; “jewish billionaires”, 9/11 and Bibi ones.
he’s venting because he seems to see a double standard in the media how casual the talk of “arab rag heads” is perceived versus some verbal insult to the jewishness of some clown and thus the ensuing brouhaha.
Calling someone who is jewish an asshole or other names doesn’t make him an AS. They’re not sacred nor is their feelings more sensitive than yours or mine.

Posted by: shanks | Nov 15 2008 14:29 utc | 21

I’ve not posted before but I couldn’t pass on this one.
Anti Arab discrimination, anti semite…hey guys my mom
cleaned floors to earn the money to put food on our table.
My mother the maid, my neighbor the garbage collector did a lot less harm in the world than any of the ruling class they worked for.
Although Rahm’s dad meant it as an insult to Arabs…it’s really an insult to the working classes of the world.

Posted by: jaydee | Nov 15 2008 18:08 utc | 22

constant,
i was very sloppy w/my post. what i meant was
‘how about constant fear, constant? does that have substance?’
i meant constant fear in the way r’giap used it
fear – the constant tool
i choose to interpret this as the tool of perception.
when i read your words, only fear makes sense, hope has no substance, i was reminded that fear is absence. it is inverse of light and understanding. yes, as you mentioned one can sense ones fears, but i disagree w/you here:fear is one of the senses (to me), a part of preception,
it is not a sense in itself, and it is for the most part caused by lack of perception. we fear an absence of sense, an absence of understanding, an absence of substantiation.
when you say ‘a part of perception’..check out substance theory, aristotle “By being ‘present in a subject’ I do not mean present as parts are present in a whole, but being incapable of existence apart from the said subject.”
i don’t think fear is part of perception because it cannot exist outside of it. whatever ‘substance’ it has is derived solely from ones perceptions. the same thing might also be said of hope. but i do not believe fear has substance and hope doesn’t because all the power they have comes from us who perceives them.
that said, i wasn’t speaking of you personally. hence your question Do you know me?, my very sloppy post wasn’t relating to you per se. your comment just struck me as unusual and didn’t align w/my reality.
more from substance theory
The argument from conception holds that properties are inconceivable by themselves and therefore it is always a substance that has the properties. Thus, it asserts, substances exist.
fear doesn’t have substance, that’s why it scares us. however, that which we fear has substance. excuse me for dropping little philosophical asides into the post.

Posted by: annie | Nov 15 2008 22:58 utc | 23

Good point, Jaydee. It was not only a racist insult, but as importantly, a classist insult.

Posted by: Obamageddon | Nov 16 2008 0:46 utc | 24

What Jaydee & Obamageddon said, along with Dan of Steel’s rant and Tangerine’s first sentence.

Posted by: Rick | Nov 16 2008 1:41 utc | 25

@shanks, you are probably right, I did say, can’t describe, haven’t read much of xymphora in the past years. Calling anyone an asshole is no sign of anything except irritation, bad temper, the impulse to dismiss or insult.
Anti-Arab-Muslim sentiment, much hyped and encouraged by the media and certain leaders, less important on the ground (no doubt everyone can come up with horrific examples, but I’ll stick with that) is pinned on 9/11, the ‘terrorist’ memes, etc.
The project of a NWO in the ME has not been abandoned.
If one sees Israel as an outpost, a small but significant toe-hold, of the US in the ME (and parts of the rest of the West under the US umbrella) at once dependent and subservient, profiteering massively, and controlling, or better, allowed to control in part, in a symbiotic relationship, then the discussions about dual loyalty or Israel firsters or what not (as in xymphora? or elsewhere at any rate) wash away.
The likes of Emanuel then become the usual imperalists who simply perceive the strategic importance of Israel and their control of it. They care nothing for the Israeli ppl, or Jews, or anything else in that register, they defend or support or pander to Israel/Jews because they have so far invested a huge amount and can’t let it go.
The ‘Anglos’ have dominated, shaped, controlled, and funded Israel.
Example: This article by Adam Shatz, about Jews in Iraq, in the London review of books is online, a good read:
On 27 April 1950 a man whose passport identified him as Richard Armstrong flew from Amsterdam to Baghdad. He came as a representative of Near East Air Transport, an American charter company seeking to win a contract with Iraq’s prime minister, Tawfiq al-Suwaida, to fly Iraqi Jews to Cyprus. (..)
link

Posted by: Tangerine | Nov 16 2008 17:36 utc | 26

Tangerine
Thanks for the lrb link, was an engrossing read; in the usual stories of any refugee cast away from his homeland.
If it was really true that the Mossad engineered the blasts to force the Iraqi jews to flee, then they’re truly fcuked.
My pet theory is that this is just a fight between Xians and Muslims with the Jews as the schmucks, the fall guys for one party, should the need arise.
In every incident with a muslim country, there is one Jew/Israeli involved whether by design or accident, thus hiding the true purpose (oil grab, gold whatever). convenient for jewish paranoia, convenient for robber barons and finally convenient for despotic regimes in their respective countries.
With religious nutters, these things get weird real fast.

Posted by: shanks | Nov 16 2008 18:10 utc | 27

tangerine, your link syncs w/the personal recollection of Naeim Giladi

Giladi discusses the crimes committed by Zionists in their frenzy to import raw Jewish labor. Newly-vacated farmlands had to be plowed to provide food for the immigrants and the military ranks had to be filled with conscripts to defend the stolen lands. Mr. Giladi couldn’t get his book published in Israel, and even in the U.S. he discovered he could do so only if he used his own money.
The Giladis, now U.S. citizens, live in New York City. By choice, they no longer hold Israeli citizenship. “I am Iraqi,” he told us, “born in Iraq, my culture still Iraqi Arabic, my religion Jewish, my citizenship American.”

scroll down to The Riots of 1941

Posted by: annie | Nov 16 2008 21:33 utc | 28

Topamax tegretol.

Topamax tegretol. Topamax. Problems with topamax. Topamax vaginal bleeding. Binge eating topamax.

Posted by: Topamax. | Jan 29 2010 14:18 utc | 29