Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
December 10, 2007
WaPo on Wearing the Skirt

The reporting about the presidential candidates is tiring. Journalists are diving deep into the ‘real’ issues. They explain in detail the concepts this or that candidate presents about health insurance, farm subsidies or trivialities like waging wars.

But nobody cares for this stuff. Too many reports are about the issues the candidates stand for. Voters don’t bother to read them. They’d rather want to know about the candidates legs.

We are therefore thankful to WaPo’s talented Robin Givhan deep meditation on the candidate who is Wearing the Skirt:

The mind, so easily distracted by things mauve and lemon yellow, strays from more pressing concerns to ponder the sartorial: How many skirts does Rudi Giuliani have in his closet? And does he ever wear them in the same combination more than once?
[…]

Men have come a long way from the time when wearing a skirt was considered "borrowing from the girls." So it would be highly regressive to suggest that the candidate is using skirts to heighten the perception that he is not only tough as a man. And yet . . .
[…]
Is even considering the former mayor’s clothes a kind of chauvinistic assault? Or is it merely the intellect trying to wrangle some sort of order out of the imagination? Oh, the tumult!
[…]
Those are the color choices of someone who not only wants to stand out, but is happy to do so in a palette that is quintessentially male. Those are not the typical color choices of East Coast chardonnay swillers, for whom black is a symbol of sophistication and Élan. Bold colors are more common in the vast midsection and southern parts of the country. Giuliani-the-human-color-wheel is wooing Ohio and Florida.

He also has made a clear visual distinction between himself as mayor and as presidential candidate. As mayor, he played to tradition, dutifully wearing pants of an unflattering length and jackets shaped like a rectangle. But now it is not so far-fetched to believe that his wardrobe is a way of reminding voters that a man can have as much peacock bravado as the girls.

Now, can’t she write?

But it is fiction. Givhan didn’t opine on Giuliani’s drag nor on  Fred Thompson’s cleavage. She is simply bothered by Hillary Clinton being a woman. Something that goes much deeper than any policy issue.

But while she is at that, musing about Giuliani would make much more sense.

Inner Circle performance 2001

Mayor’s Inner Circle Press Roast 2000

Video’s:
Rudy Giuliani with Donald Trump
He’s Da Man!
He Feels Pretty

Slideshow:
Rudy in Leather and Lace

Comments

Indeed, the mind boggles to comprehend, no, simply to consider imagining the depravity of the MSM. True, Givhan is a “mode” reporter, but still, how Rudy can continue to be put out as a serious contender is beyond me.
What I think is that H.C. Andersen was wrong, out to lunch — when the little boy cries, “The Imperator has no clothes!”, the spin starts proclaiming “…how brave and noble the Imperator was to parade like this, showing his trust of the people.”
Other than that, I think Rudy has a bad taste in lipstick.

Posted by: Chuck Cliff | Dec 10 2007 19:49 utc | 1

It seems that in American presidential politics, wearing a skirt is only remarkable when the candidate is a woman.

Posted by: aubanel | Dec 10 2007 20:11 utc | 2

It seems that in American presidential politics, wearing a skirt is only remarkable when the candidate is a woman.

Posted by: aubanel | Dec 10 2007 20:11 utc | 3

Apologies for the double post, troubles with Javascript.

Posted by: aubanel | Dec 10 2007 20:13 utc | 4

Bravo, Bernhard!
Forgive me if I quote these uproarious lines from your caricature …

Bold colors are more common in the vast midsection and southern parts of the country. Giuliani-the-human-color-wheel is wooing Ohio and Florida.

As mayor, he played to tradition, dutifully wearing pants of an unflattering length and jackets shaped like a rectangle.

I have detested Giuliani since seeing him “perform” at a staged meeting at an uptown school after some violent episode, pretending to answer questions from troubled students but instead posturing with tough-guy language,
“How you feel about your safety in New York when someone brings a knife to school? I don’t care how you feel.
You must report him to the school and police authorities! Immediately!”
But I never noticed his laughable square-man outline in flood pants … thanks again.

Posted by: jonku | Dec 10 2007 20:56 utc | 5

Mossad must have so must stuff on this guy his is a strap-on kinda guy, sorry shoe-in.

Posted by: Cloned Poster | Dec 10 2007 21:24 utc | 6

I would say that Giuliani definitely has tendencies personally towards crossdressing. It is not just theatricality. There are four occasions on the slideshow linked.
Crossdressing is, of course, a perfectly legitimate activity, which does no harm to anyone.
On a political level, I would say that these videos will not affect his vote among women. Women do not mind if a man dresses as one of them, as long as it is not their own husband, in which case bad vibes. Men, especially conservatives, can be expected to be contemptuous, as though the man is of a lower order, and no doubt that was the reason for the publicity, and release, of the videos.
However, evidently, 50% of the voting population are women.
I would think that the main effect will be among the male-dominated political classes in Washington, and among the male-dominated donors of funds to Republican candidates.

Posted by: Alex | Dec 10 2007 21:39 utc | 7

Damn it. I got a stiffie!

Posted by: Diogenes | Dec 10 2007 23:30 utc | 8

Rudy is not sexy. He does not arouse erotic envy disguised as moral indignation. The base will identify with him.

Posted by: rjj | Dec 11 2007 0:43 utc | 9

Folks I need some help. Remember a few years ago Billmon published a witty comparison between Mao’s cultural revolution and the anti-intellectual rhetoric of David Horowitz? I can really use it right now. If anyone has a link to the mirror site, please send me a link. At my school, the fascist are trying to take over. I need more ammunition.

Posted by: Diogenes | Dec 11 2007 1:14 utc | 10

#10
the unofficial archive

Posted by: rudolf | Dec 11 2007 3:49 utc | 11

Any thread that brings in both Jonku & Diogenes is great 🙂
Diogenes, I thght. you were at a small liberal arts school in Maine? Tell us more. Is this administrative, or faculty? What’s student body like, other than lost & terrified facing million dollars mortgages & all the jobs being destroyed? Are you referring to Political Fascists or Theocrats. (If the latter, I presume you read Chris Hedges new bk. on the subject.)
As far as Givens objecting to women – it’s far more efficient to bring in females to do the hatchet job. See also Oprah turning out the sheep for Obama this wkend. Makes my blood run cold.
B- forgot to mention that when Rudi – proper drag queen spelling – stayed w/his male homosexual friends, he kissed them goodbye every day. Wonder if he’s had an affair w/Johnny Thoroughly Rotten Roberts. Wouldn’t that be funny!!!

Posted by: jj | Dec 11 2007 6:27 utc | 12

Remember a few years ago Billmon published a witty comparison between Mao’s cultural revolution and the anti-intellectual rhetoric of David Horowitz?
diogenes, do you remember the timeframe?
there’s always whiskey bar w/no search. the farther back you go….i tend to get lost.
here’s the archive by date. don’t get toooo lost.
i can’t help it, i miss him.

Posted by: annie | Dec 11 2007 6:53 utc | 13

Hillary pics – funny and disturbing

Posted by: b | Dec 11 2007 9:21 utc | 14

Giuliani – Next president of the US.
Skirt, lipstick, lies, Catholic sinner, Mafia contact, whatever. No matter. There it is, so it is.

Posted by: Tangerine | Dec 11 2007 15:48 utc | 15

Giuliani – Next president of the US.
Skirt, lipstick, lies, Catholic sinner, pro abortionist, Mafia contact, (ex..) whatever. No matter. Those things don’t matter.
There it is.

Posted by: Tangerine | Dec 11 2007 16:03 utc | 16

Looking through the pictures of H, I think it made me more sympathetic toward her, same thing happened when they went after Bill.

Posted by: anna missed | Dec 11 2007 19:42 utc | 17

b, Oprah’s endorsement of Obama is big time…. any views etc?

Posted by: Cloned Poster | Dec 11 2007 19:57 utc | 18