Government reports are not neutral, but express the general tendencies of the administrations politics. See the just released International Narcotics Control Strategy Report. It even confuses the person responsible for it. In her release briefing Mrs. Patterson manages to contradict her own report several times.
The report:
The Islamic Republic of Iran is a major transit route for opiates smuggled from Afghanistan and through Pakistan to the Persian Gulf, Turkey, Russia, and Europe. The largest single share of opiates leaving Afghanistan (perhaps 60 percent) passes through Iran to consumers in Iran itself, Russia and Europe.
International Narcotics Control Strategy Report-2007
Released by the Bureau of International Narcotics and Law Enforcement Affairs
March 2007
The briefing:
QUESTION: I have one more follow up. You are listing (inaudible) list that Pakistan is a major drug trafficking and money laundering center. How can you explain this? Where are the drugs coming and going through Pakistan?
ASSISTANT SECRETARY PATTERSON: There’s a legal definition of what a major trafficking — and it’s in the front part of that report — and yeah, sure, Pakistan because they take at least somewhere between half and two-thirds of the Afghan product moves through Pakistan.
Release of the 2007 International Narcotics Control Strategy Report
Anne W. Patterson, Assistant Secretary for International Narcotics and Law Enforcement Affairs –
On-The-Record Briefing – Washington, DC – March 1, 2007
The report:
Afghanistan remained the world’s largest producer of opium in 2006, cultivating 172,600 hectares of opium poppy according to USG estimates. This equates to 5,644 metric tons of opium, up from 4,475 metric tons in 2005.
International Narcotics Control Strategy Report-2007
Released by the Bureau of International Narcotics and Law Enforcement Affairs
March 2007
The briefing:
Afghanistan’s opium poppy cultivation increased by an alarming 59 percent, making last year’s crop the largest on record.
Release of the 2007 International Narcotics Control Strategy Report
Anne W. Patterson, Assistant Secretary for International Narcotics and Law Enforcement Affairs –
On-The-Record Briefing – Washington, DC – March 1, 2007
Bonus issue – Venezuela:
Prepared remarks:
Venezuela’s permissive and corrupt environment led to more trafficking, fewer seizures, and an increase in suspected drug flights over the past 12 months. From 2005 to 2006 there was a 167 percent increase in cocaine trafficked via air to Hispaniola.
A smart reporter during the Q&A:
QUESTION: Anyway, on the second question, which is more — you say that — on Venezuela that there was a 167 percent increase in cocaine traffic (inaudible) to — I presume this is Haiti and the DR. How do you know this? Are there seizures that —
ASSISTANT SECRETARY PATTERSON: Because we track — we have very good information on air tracks. And what’s essentially happened is what the — what used to come through Colombia by air has now been virtually eliminated through a very successful program called air bridge denial and pushed eastward into Venezuela.
QUESTION: Okay.
ASSISTANT SECRETARY PATTERSON: And a lot of product is also moving from Colombia by land into Venezuela where it’s put on small planes and goes into Haiti and the Dominican Republic.
QUESTION: And your information is on the weight of this amount or just on the number of planes?
ASSISTANT SECRETARY PATTERSON: No, on the — on the number of tracks we’ve seen. And there’s a complicated formula that derives that. It’s about 9 percent of U.S. supply.
QUESTION: Yeah, but I’m just not sure I understand how you get 170 —
ASSISTANT SECRETARY PATTERSON: Okay, we’ll give you that.
QUESTION: — 167 percent increase in cocaine when you haven’t actually weighed it. I mean, you’re talking about an increase in the number of flights, right?
ASSISTANT SECRETARY PATTERSON: We’re talking about an increase in the number of flights.
QUESTION: Of which you do — which may or may not have illicit drugs on them?
ASSISTANT SECRETARY PATTERSON: Well, that’s true. But we have many years of statistical history on this —
Release of the 2007 International Narcotics Control Strategy Report
Anne W. Patterson, Assistant Secretary for International Narcotics and Law Enforcement Affairs –
On-The-Record Briefing – Washington, DC – March 1, 2007
Unfortunately, such bogus reports have consequences. When newspapers write "Report slams Venezuela for drug trafficking," people immediately assign guilt. Of course that is why the effort is made …