Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
November 3, 2006
A General’s Art

A transition is not always a pleasant thing to watch as it happens.  But when common goals are achieved, speed bumps and differences of opinion along the way are soon forgotten.  Every great work of art goes through messy phases while it is in transition.  A lump of clay can become a sculpture; blobs of paint become paintings which inspire.
Maj. Gen. William B. Caldwell IV, November 02, 2006


A woman reacts as she looks at the body of her son-in-law, right, in a hospital yard in Baqouba, 60 kilometers (35 miles) northeast of Baghdad, Thursday Nov. 2, 2006. A total of eleven bodies were discovered by police in Baqouba Thursday. (Photo AP)

“Three U.S. armed vehicles, eight soldiers in each, are driving through a village, passing candy out to kids,” he began. “Suddenly the first vehicle explodes, and there are soldiers screaming. Sixteen soldiers come out of the other vehicles, and they do what they’re told to do, which is look for running people.”

“Never mind that the bomb was detonated by remote control,” Hersh continued. “[The soldiers] open up fire; [the] cameras show it was a soccer game.”

“About ten minutes later, [the soldiers] begin dragging bodies together, and they drop weapons there. It was reported as 20 or 30 insurgents killed that day,” he said.
[…]
“In Vietnam, our soldiers came back and they were reviled as baby killers, in shame and humiliation,” he said. “It isn’t happening now, but I will tell you – there has never been an [American] army as violent and murderous as our army has been in Iraq.”
Hersh

Comments

Art that Hitler would approve of. For sure. Burn in hell Caldwell the 4th.

Posted by: beq | Nov 3 2006 12:13 utc | 1

Whole heartedly agree beq…
The Reader will thank me from refraining from citing the obligatory _Godel, Escher, Bach: The Eternal Golden Braid_ here. Similarly, we will allow others
to muse on possible fractals underlying Jackson Pollock, “The Square Root of
Minus One,” and Crowley’s mindfuck, “Bereshith: An Essay In Ontology,” among other things. Cantor’s Infinite Sets? You go ahead.
The great Hungarian number theorist Paul Erdos – like most of my typing here, this seems apropos of nada – once defined a mathematician as “a machine for turning coffee into theorems.
Funny how Caldwell the 4th’s art exceeds Jackson Pollock art in price eh?
Blood, oil, sweat and tears.
Of course, being as some say, ‘order out of chaos, khaos out of order’…
Yes, I’m drunk again, what’s it to ya… ;-p

Posted by: Uncle $cam | Nov 3 2006 13:02 utc | 2

Must teach Art appreciation at West Point.
A well-rounded guy, that one.

Posted by: Anonymous | Nov 3 2006 13:22 utc | 3

Art is hell…

Posted by: ralphieboy | Nov 3 2006 14:00 utc | 4

If this be art, here is it’s shadow, the tragic opera, The Rape of Lucretia Gaza

Posted by: Uncle $cam | Nov 3 2006 14:11 utc | 5

Rumsfeld has made such a load of rubbish decisions during this “war” that it’s hard to know where to begin, but his chief error was believing that the people of Iraq could be intimidated into submission through excessive application of force. This was how he thought he could compensate for the low number of soldiers he had at his disposal inside the country.
U.S. Force Protection Rules during the occupation of Iraq have been nothing short of murderous. Of course we reel in incomprehension when the number 650.000 Iraqi dead as a result of the invasion – but there’s absolutely no reason to think that the true number is anywhere near the 30.000 touted by Bush.
From artillery, infantrymen, helicopters, planes and navy platforms Iraqis have been under fire for forty two months now, day in and day out. To keep U.S. casualties low, the general rule has been shoot first until you run out of ammunition, and then see who else can help keep up the fire.
It is absolutely disgusting what Rumsfeld and his henchmen have done in Iraq and I know that readers will react negatively when I say so, but the behavior of SS troops in Slav occupied territories during WWII is probably the nearest comparison that can be drawn.
The story will, of course, come out – and when it does so, it is to be hoped that the world will take those responsible to account. The war crimes of Milosevic pale in comparison.

Posted by: SteinL | Nov 3 2006 15:49 utc | 6

Bernard thanks for posting this. I’ve done a posting – took me a few hours. I had to keep on stopping.
I can’t stop thinking about Ilse Koch and I can’t stop thinking about how many Iraqis are getting tattoos done so that they can be identified if they’re tortured killed and dumped sans ID.
I’ve put in various links in the posting. But this is the one about Iraqis getting tattooed for ID purposes:
These tattoos aren’t artful – they help identify Iraq’s dead – By Nancy A. Youssef McClatchy Newspapers

Posted by: markfromireland | Nov 3 2006 16:10 utc | 7

that caldwell press briefing @uncles#15… classic.
check out how he deal w/the weapons questions

Q Shakel Ahmed (ph) with the BBC, the Arabic BBC. There are some mechanisms worked out by the American and the Iraqi administration like equipping the Iraqi security forces with weapons. Have you activated this process?
GEN. CALDWELL: The question is, is there an ongoing process by which we’re having a dialogue in how to equip the Iraqi security forces, if I have your question correctly. Is that right?
And the answer to that is, yes, there is, in fact. And there is a — as you just heard recently from the discussions that the prime minister had with the president of the United States, there was an agreement and a high-level commission has been formed specifically to take on addressing both the acceleration of the equipping and manning of the Iraqi security forces, accelerating the passing of the command and control of those Iraqi security forces to the government of Iraq, and that committee has been formed as officially this week.
clip
The prime minister made the decision he was going to enlarge his armed forces. He made the announcement this past week. He said he wanted more command and control headquarters, he wanted more deployable forces, he wanted a Special Operations battalion. He made all those decisions and made the announcement, and they’re going to go ahead and increase the size of their force by about 18,796 to achieve that goal. So I mean, he is making those decisions.
clip
Q Jamie Tarabay from National Public Radio.Given all the focus on additional Iraqi forces and security, et cetera, what do you make of the comments by the prime minister last week in an interview in which he said that he was too afraid to put his police up against militias because they didn’t have enough weapons? I mean, he even said the police had to share rifles. So how does that, you know, jibe with all the focus on bringing in new forces and making sure that they’re ready?
Thank you.
GEN. CALDWELL: Well, look, what I’ll tell you, Jamie, is we maintain continual dialogue, and we need to have more dialogue, as was clearly evidenced by the fact that there has been some disconnects that have occurred in this transition period. We’re listening very closely to what the prime minister and his government are asking for, and we’re going to make sure that we’re continuing to address those issues.
The whole purpose behind this high-level commission that the president of the United States and the prime minister agreed upon is specifically so he can walk into the room there and have the president of the United States’ representative, the ambassador from the United States there, along with General Casey, commander of the multinational force, where he can raise these things at the highest level to ensure that they are properly addressed and adequately responded to in the way that he would like to see them done.

what a joke. last spring they said the new plan was to start doing sweeps, they were going to start in august. they call it ‘clearing ‘ areas. now we have a situation where the iraqis are in charge but we need to do sweeps because we are looking for the one lone mising husband. we have done a number ofsweeps but will need to go out and do more. even tho we have leads we don’t have him.
why do i think this is bs? let me count the ways.

Posted by: annie | Nov 3 2006 16:23 utc | 8

Uncle $cam here’s a modern Lebanese Pieta

Posted by: markfromireland | Nov 3 2006 16:25 utc | 9

Of course we reel in incomprehension when the number 650.000 Iraqi dead as a result of the invasion

It’s worth reading the article (abstract). Sorry, you do have to register, but it’s free and pretty harmless.
The article is not particularly technical and is clearly written, and it’s pretty clear that any death toll below 300,000 is completely implausible.

Posted by: Araneidae | Nov 3 2006 16:30 utc | 10

mark, your link doesn’t work

Posted by: annie | Nov 3 2006 18:03 utc | 11

Annie could you let me know which link doesn’t work? The one to the “pieta” or the one to the story by Nancy Youssef? (I’ve just right clicked on each and they’re coming up here.)

Posted by: markfromireland | Nov 3 2006 18:43 utc | 12

The link to the pieta did not work for me, but the link to the Youssef story did, and reading it left a very powerful sense of nausea in my gut… not a story that I will soon forget.

Posted by: Bea | Nov 3 2006 18:57 utc | 13

markfromIreland
I get a Forbidden
Error 403 at your “pieta” link…

Posted by: Uncle $cam | Nov 3 2006 18:58 utc | 14

exactly mark, i checked on both safari and foxfire

Posted by: annie | Nov 3 2006 19:00 utc | 15

@Araneidae #10
Anyway to liberate that story?

Posted by: Uncle $cam | Nov 3 2006 19:02 utc | 16

Oh sod – that makes sense I’m logged into blogger so of course it’s letting me see me own photos. Sorry folks. A bit brain busted today.
The photo can be seen on this posting on “Gorilla’s Guides” checking the posting I see it was Siun who called it a pieta. Which is obviously where my subconscious dragged it up from.

Posted by: markfromireland | Nov 3 2006 19:18 utc | 17

Uncle, Well Crowley was of a rare, crazed, wild flamboyance, admired or vilified…but Cantor…no escapin’ him, though it is a bit of high falutin’ trickery…
There are some that suggest that Crowley might be George W. Bush’s grand-father.
Cannonfire
Nobody has tried to relate him to the Cantors. 😉 🙂

Posted by: Noirette | Nov 3 2006 20:21 utc | 18

I just reclicked on the link once the 403 came up and it took me to the pic. I sorta wish it hadn’t not that it is particularly grisly. Grisly I can take, heartrending is harder.

Posted by: Debs is dead | Nov 3 2006 20:30 utc | 19

fwiw. I got to both of the links. Article on second try.

Posted by: beq | Nov 3 2006 20:30 utc | 20

Jesus – that Lunatic is a leader in our military?

Posted by: Fade | Nov 3 2006 20:31 utc | 21

Yeah, him Boykin … you think they’re bad try some of the Airforce folks …
“Mad bad and dangerous to know”

Posted by: markfromireland | Nov 3 2006 20:52 utc | 22

ahhh, just used to old ‘cyberpunk’ login for
Araneidae’s #10 it worked…
Username:cyberpunk
Password:cyberpunk
Old trick still works….

Posted by: Uncle $cam | Nov 3 2006 20:52 utc | 23

Apparently some brilliant US social scientists have coined a lovely little new phrase for guided civil war: Ethnic demixing.
Reported by Badger at How US intellectual fads mirror, in a dream-like way, the military “strategy”

Posted by: Alamet | Nov 3 2006 23:32 utc | 24

chris floyd writing like the wind at empire burlesque
(sorry ’bout the cut & paste but i think it’s important)
dgame: The Lights Are Going Out All Over Baghdad
Friday, 03 November 2006
While the American election campaign thrashes toward the finish line with the usual spasms of witless diversion and hyper-mendacity – an echo chamber of utter bullshit roaring in a media bubble murderously detached from reality – in the actual world of flesh and blood, the destruction of Iraq engineered by George W. Bush is entering a new phase that could make the previous three years of all-devouring hell look like a sojourn in paradise.
Baghdad is under siege, as Patrick Cockburn reports in the Independent; the city has been encircled by Sunni militias who have cut almost all the roads leading into the capital. Inside the city, “the scale of killing is already as bad as Bosnia at the height of the Balkans conflict,” says Cockburn. And it will inevitably, inexorably grow worse, as Shiite militias consolidate their hold within Baghdad while trying to break the blockade from outside. Already, “food shortages are becoming severe” in some parts of the city, he reports, while almost a thousand Iraqis are being slaughtered each week, mostly in Baghdad. Meanwhile, at least 1.5 million internal refugees have fled the ethnic cleansing by both Sunni and Shiite militias, joining the hundreds of thousands who have fled the country altogether. Again, these numbers dwarf those in the Bosnian and Kosovo wars – while the total dead from Bush’s war, a very credible estimate of at least 650,000, is approaching the level of the Rwandan genocide.
And as Cockburn notes, the American presence in the city provides the people no security, no stability – only confusion. First, the U.S. pours in fresh troops for a month-long campaign to “reclaim” the city for the Iraqi government – but this only intensifies the killing and sectarian control of Baghdad, and is called off, an openly acknowledged failure. Then the Americans launch a fierce hunt for a kidnapped U.S. soldier in the very heart of the Shiite section, only to abruptly abandon this too after a carefully orchestrated display of pique by Nouri al-Maliki, the powerless prime minister of the supposedly “sovereign” state. The captured American was left behind, at the order of the Pentagon and the White House, while the radical extremists led by cleric Motqada Sadr – the “essential prop” of al-Maliki’s Bush-backed government, as Cockburn notes – took to the streets to celebrate this victory over the Americans.
None of this has penetrated the American media bubble: the genocidal killing, the abandonment of a U.S. captive, the sealing off of Baghdad, the imminent loss of even the semblance of “Coalition” control in the country. Although some Democrats have started to make hay with a general critique of the war – criticisms often couched in terms of Bush “not doing it right,” as if there was a right way to carry out an unprovoked war of aggression – the full reality of what’s happening in Iraq now is universally unacknowledged by the American establishment. Some look to the “Baker Commission” – the usual gaggle of the “great and good,” led here by Bush Family fixer James Baker with a remit to produce “new ideas” on the war – for ways to remedy the deteriorating situation. But the Baker panel’s conclusion – which it has thoughtfully withheld until after the election, thereby letting hundreds of Iraqis and dozens of American soldiers die for the sake of the Bush Faction’s political fortunes – will have already been outstripped by reality before they are even uttered. They will amount to no more than a new shade of lipstick for Bush’s pig of a war – a bloodsoaked sow eating her own farrow.
The endgame has begun. And whether the Americans withdraw to a few “superbases” in the desert, or “redeploy” over the border in Kuwait, or have to fight their way out of the Green Zone in a mad dash for the last transports leaving the airport, nothing will stop the bloodbath that Bush and his henchmen have set in motion. They have destroyed the Iraqi state and Iraqi society – along with vast swathes of the Iraqi population – and the consequences of this moral insanity, this willful, deliberate evil, will be terrible to behold.
But of course, none of this is as important as John Kerry’s bad joke, is it?
Excerpts from The Independent: As American and British political leaders argue over responsibility for the crisis in Iraq, the country has taken another lurch towards disintegration.
Well-armed Sunni tribes now largely surround Baghdad and are fighting Shia militias to complete the encirclement.
The Sunni insurgents seem to be following a plan to control all the approaches to Baghdad. They have long held the highway leading west to the Jordanian border and east into Diyala province. Now they seem to be systematically taking over routes leading north and south. Dusty truck-stop and market towns such as Mahmoudiyah, Balad and Baquba all lie on important roads out of Baghdad. In each case Sunni fighters are driving out the Shia and tightening their grip on the capital. Shias may be in a strong position within Baghdad but they risk their lives when they take to the roads. Some 30 Shias were dragged off a bus yesterday after being stopped at a fake checkpoint south of Balad…
In reality the militias are growing stronger by the day because the Shia and Sunni communities feel threatened and do not trust the army and police to defend them. US forces have been moving against the Mehdi Army, which follows the nationalist cleric Muqtada al-Sadr, but he is an essential prop to Mr Maliki’s government. Almost all the main players in Iraqi politics maintain their own militias. The impotence of US forces to prevent civil war is underlined by the fact that the intense fighting between Sunni and Shia around Balad, north of Baghdad, has raged for a month, although the town is beside one of Iraq’s largest American bases. The US forces have done little and when they do act they are seen by the Shia as pursuing a feud against the Mehdi Army…
Another ominous development is that Iraqi tribes that often used to have both Sunni and Shia members are now splitting along sectarian lines.
In Baghdad it has become lethally dangerous for a Sunni to wander into a Shia neighbourhood and vice versa. In one middle-class district called al-Khudat, in west Baghdad, once favoured by lawyers and judges, the remaining Shia families recently found a cross in red paint on their doors. Sometimes there is also a note saying “leave without furniture and without renting your house”. Few disobey.

Posted by: remembereringgiap | Nov 3 2006 23:55 utc | 25