Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
August 19, 2006
WB: Stability

Billmon:

So instability is good, but Hizbullah is a force for instability, which is bad. But Hizbullah lost the war, which is good, so it can’t be a force for instability any more, which could be bad or good, depending on what day of the week it is and whether or not Shrub has been hitting the sauce again.

Stability

Comments

Alas, where to put this…
It doesn’t get any more facts on the ground than this…Class war in the IDF written by a Staff Sgt. (res).
On a hill near Jebel Bilat, on the evening of August 7, 2006, a supply convoy with reinforcements was being delayed. The cause: brigade commander Colonel Shlomi Cohen’s convoy was getting public relations services from Yedioth Ahronoth reporter, Nahum Barnea. The Colonel received another dose of “promotion coverage,” and his soldiers, who did not receive supplies, had to break into local shops and steal foodstuffs.
On a hilltop overlooking the bay of Tyre at 8:30 AM, on August 15, 2006, slightly more than 24 hours since the cease-fire went into effect, reconnaissance unit 609 is sitting in a Lebanese house, taking cover from the anti-tank missiles that could appear at any moment. They are not sure about what the next day will bring.
The sniper on team 3 is waiting to receive a warning that he will be fired. He has been away from his new job for a month. The medic, the team leader and the guy handling the grenade launcher are unsure about what to do with the semester exams that they have missed. Those who are single are planning to flee the country. The family men are due home to wives who have not slept for a month, to children dying for their embrace, but also to mortgages and the rest of the payments that need to be made.
On the map, the company’s movement looks like a green arrow, cutting through on the right of the security zone in a semi-circle. On the generals’ maps, it is yet another promise to increase the defense budget, salaries for the career staff and for their stock options in their own personal, crazy start-up called “the next war.” Just like in any war, there are winners and losers.
On the hills covered in pine and cypress trees in Israel, the fighting class is burying its dead and licking its wounds. The commanding class is granting another interview to reporters and waiting for the findings of the committees of inquiry. The debate over the budget has already been won, and the aid from the U.S. is already on the way. Just like in any war, there are winners and losers.

Posted by: jj | Aug 19 2006 5:12 utc | 1

Up is down and down is up in Bushworld until down is up and up is down!

Posted by: ab initio | Aug 19 2006 5:44 utc | 2

Israeli Commando Raid in Eastern Lebanon Shakes Fragile Ceasefire

A Lebanese military official told Agence France Presse that Israeli helicopters, under the cover of mock raids by warplanes, landed two Hummer vehicles in the mountainous region of Afqa, about 30 kilometers east of Baalbeck, a Hizbullah stronghold.
Commandos then drove eastward to the nearby village of Buday where they clashed with Hizbullah fighters, he said.
The incident marks the first major clash between the two sides since a fragile ceasefire took effect on Monday.
The Israeli army would neither confirm nor deny the attack, but a Hizbullah spokesman did confirm it.
There were exchanges of fire in south Lebanon earlier this week that left at least four Hizbullah fighters dead.

Posted by: b | Aug 19 2006 7:43 utc | 3

The animist in me would have to say that we have reached the pinnical of moral relativism with this rovian consciousness, that a central character of modernism, ambiguity, has been fully realized. In contrast, animist society would be un-ironic, and un-ambiguious — but at the same time acknowledge and pay pennence to their dark side by celebration and repayment through social welfare. Denial and contradiction then, become unnecessary.

Posted by: anna missed | Aug 19 2006 7:51 utc | 4

Ghaith Abdul-Ahad from Lebanon: The fight reflex

Abu Ali, a commander from Amal, is tall, bald and missing two fingers from his left hand. He walked around Khiam inspecting damage and looking for his men. “We don’t have the same capabilities as Hizbullah, so we had to rely on them for IEDs [improvised explosive devices] and rockets, but we fought together. They didn’t consult us when they started the war, but when you see the Israelis it doesn’t matter any more.
“On Thursday morning, a column of Israeli tanks tried to come to the town. We were waiting for them in the low lands between Khiam and Marjeyoun. We were four groups of Hizbullah and Amal fighters, we fired at them from everywhere, we hit few tanks and they couldn’t retrieve them till Sunday night.”

Interesting that Amal fought too.

Posted by: b | Aug 19 2006 11:01 utc | 5

@anna missed you’re right men a lot closer to their life force do become the penitant but that that isn’t always what it’s cracked up to be.
Years ago a friend I had been surfing with in Bali for a couple of weeks persuaded me to go to the north of the island and meet his family before I went home. I rented a shitty suzuki ‘suv’ with a sewing machine engine and we headed off with Wayan driving as “he knew the way”. I handed over my fate very early on in the piece since it soon became obvious that Wayan’s driving ambitions vastly exceeded his ability, and his idea of being the best driver was getting away with crazier things than the other mad drivers on the road.
Somewhere north of Chandi Dasa we turned off the road and headed inland through a bush track, sorry road. Since Wayan’s claimed knowledge of his home territory convinced him he knew every inch of the road, he sped up. It wasn’t long before the inevitable happened, we hit a bump going into a turn and sailed straight ahead off the the road at about 60mph. Natch the Suzuki was about as much protection as a matchbox, being an open top with cut off doors and no seat belts, so I’m sitting there thinking this is it. Goodbye cruel world n all that as we go flying thru the jungle. Two major miracles kept us alive. Firstly Wayan must have been so surprised by events he kept the stering wheel still and the wheels straight, his previous driving feats had shown me that if he had thought of it he would have tried to turn the corner in mid air. The second miracle was that all the trees sort of jumped out of the way. I’m not kidding we missed them all by some amazing chance and after about what seemed like 5 minutes but was closer to 5 seconds we slammed into the soft leaf mould and gunge that carpet jungle floors and came to a halt.
Didn’t even hit my head on the windscreen which is truly a miracle since the old melon is covered in dents and scars from accidents, fights and falls. Not this time. Anyway Suzy sewing machine went on strike after that, just wouldn’t start and Wayan reckoned we were only a spit away from his village where we could get a tow and his uncle could fix the ‘car’, so we grabbed our bags and headed back to the road and a long hot walk.
Everything else was pretty much as Wayan had promised. We had a great time with the family who still lived traditionally meaning most days were a festival of one god or spirit or another. Incredibly hospitable people and had a great time, after a few days we grabbed Wayan’s uncle and pulled suzy outta the bush onto the track then towed her back to the village where sami the uncle soon got her back to her roaring, missing, back-firing, rattling self.
A few days after that it was time to get back to Kuta then Denpassar. Just before we headed off, Wayan took a basket of woven bannana leaves holding rice, bananas and blossoms up to the village altar where he left them after lighting a couple of joss sticks. We hadn’t got more than a mile down the round when he stopped again to make an offering to “his spirit” he said. There was a beautiful little altar set in a clearing just off the road, where travellers had been leaving offerings for centuries probably, and always much appreciated by those anagrams of gods – dogs.
I had never seen Wayan so religious. This was strictly a party boy eg surfin when the rest of his family are working their ases off to keep the food on the table, so I asked him what was with all the offerings. He said “The gods protected our lives the day when the car broke” (That was another thing, the flying incident was due to a faulty car, evidenced by the fact it wouldn’t start afterwards) “so I must thank them and pay them back.”
With that he put the pedal too the metal and took off down the road. It seemed about twice as fast as we had come up it when we took flight before.
I shouted at him (well maybe screamed and begged) to slow down, but he ignored me. Finally after an even more hair raising trip down the track than we had up it when we stopped at the intersection to get back on the main road where a convoy of army trucks was passing (Wayan may have been crazy but not silly. The army always has the right of way) I reached across and grabbed the keys out of the ignition and said something along the lines of –
“Whatthefuck d’ya thinkyerdoin? Trying to kill us”
Wayan looked at me like I was the crazy one and said as if to a child. “Don’t worry we can’t be hurt. I have paid the gods, they will protect us”
In other words after having made his offerings, he felt sufficiently safe to drive even faster since we were now even better protected than the day we we missed a huge fuckin tree by about a inch when flying through the air at a lunatic speed.
You’d have to put Dubya into that school of animism I’d reckon. Sort of “See what did I tell ya the gods are on our side we’ve cut them in big time so now we can do what the fuck we like.”

Posted by: Debs is dead | Aug 19 2006 11:36 utc | 6

Below are snippets from an article (a Juan Cole link) interviewing Milt Bearden, an ex CIA person who ran the U.S. covet war in Afganistan years ago. In the article, a hypothetical question might be asked by Iran: What’s the Catch?
PADAVICK: A very important issue obviously is how Iran is looking to emerge from this.
BEARDEN: They haven’t been hurt at all. First off, Hezbollah is the current darling of everybody in the Middle East, and even the Sunni-Shia thing is put aside from that, mainly because of what they’ve accomplished by not being destroyed. And if you step back and look at a larger piece of the Middle East, the Iranians must wake up every morning and say, “What’s the catch?”
“Think about it. They’ve got a Shia south of Iraq. They’ve got the Shia that could emerge as the dominant force in Lebanon. They’ve got the Americans bogged down forever doing the Shias’ heavy lifting in the Sunni areas of Iraq. Kurdistan is independent already in [northern Iraq]. And we’ve got ourselves a narco-state war in Afghanistan that goes on without end. What would you say? You’d say, “What’s the catch?”

(snip)
The push for democracy in countries like Egypt, Jordan and Saudi Arabia is off the table now. They can say, “look, we have our own problems just like you see in Lebanon, and we can’t let [Islamic parties] win an election because we’d have the same thing that’s happened there, or happened in Gaza, and you know how bad that is, so give us a little slack here.”
We all know there is “no catch”… Bush is simply an idiot.

Posted by: Rick Happ | Aug 19 2006 13:44 utc | 7

@did:
Nice story. I was wondering how you were going to pull that one back on to the greater narrative road.

Posted by: Malooga | Aug 19 2006 13:51 utc | 8

DiD,
Balinese culture, from what I know, is one of the best on the planet. A friend of mine spent some time there, and said they were ambivalent (and most un-curious) toward western culture and technology. He figured they knew the difference and preferred their own over it.

Posted by: anna missed | Aug 19 2006 18:05 utc | 9

War is like diplomacy . . . for sick, stupid people.

Posted by: ferd | Aug 19 2006 21:26 utc | 10

Where is the Outrage
By JoelBlock
Shalom:
This was written by a good friend of mine, Arlene Cohen, of Kiryat Motzkin. It was published as commentary on Joseph Farah’s Wed, 16 Aug, 2006 edition of WorldNetDaily (www.wnd.com) You can see it there also by clicking ‘Commentary’ on the upper left side list of sections, and scrolling down until you see my name. Arlene was gracious enough to give me permission to place it on my Blog.
Joel
Where is the Outrage
It’s like dejá vu all over again. Then, more than thirty years ago, I lived in the United States where I was born and raised. Yasser Arafat was sending his mighty warriors into Israel to storm schoolyards and hijack buses, and the press was calling him a ‘guerilla leader.’ I looked it up. Sure enough, guerilla warfare had absolutely nothing to do with killing unarmed civilians. Where, I wondered, was the outrage? Why were such heinous acts being tolerated by the world, and why was the press deliberately misleading the public about them?
Today, living in Israel just north of Haifa, after a month of daily warning sirens and Katyusha rockets, listening to Nasrallah rant about his victory and Lebanese officials say they’re not going to do ‘Israel’s job’ and disarm the Hezbollah, I wonder again, where is the outrage? Why isn’t the world demanding that the terrorists be disarmed once and for all, and why is the news media still misleading the public with doctored photos?
Except for my address, nothing much has changed. There is no outrage for terrorists or anything they do, or for those who arm and support them, only for Israel’s ‘disproportionate response.’
Hearing that phrase reminds me of Time Magazine in the 1980’s, when they were virtually blaming Israel for every atrocity Arafat committed. After all, their reasoning seemed to go, the poor man wouldn’t have to go around killing and maiming folks if Israel would just stop being so darned intransigent and give in to his demands. So, in 1985, PLO henchmen board this yacht in Larnaca, Cyprus and slaughter three vacationing Israelis. Time reports the entire story in a small box. The following week, however, they devote several pages to Israel’s retaliatory strike on Arafat’s headquarters in Tunisia, complete with detailed maps and full-color photos. I suppose that’s considered ‘proportionate reporting.’
One has to wonder what the world might be like today if the press had not chosen to peddle Yasser Arafat as some kind of hero. If the world had not given him free rein to unleash the dogs of terrorism upon Israel for more than three decades. If from the very beginning reason and international law had prevailed, rightfully dictating that no cause justifies the murder of innocent people. Not even Israeli people.
Certainly, thousands of lives would have been saved—Israeli, Palestinian and many others, quite probably including the victims of 9/11. For it is very likely that there would not be today’s proliferation of terrorist organizations, all of whom learned their craft from the master, Yasser Arafat. Blowing up airplanes, car bombs, suicide bombers, human shields—he developed and used these tactics long before there was an al-Qaeda or Hamas or Hezbollah.
But Arafat’s greatest weapon against Israel was the news media, which became the platform from which he spread the lies and created the myths that influenced world opinion and government policies alike. The lies were legion, and repeated verbatim so often in the news that many became ‘truth’ in the public mind.
As a result, much of the world believes that Israel stole the ‘occupied territories’ from some pre-existing Palestinian Arab nation, when in truth, no such nation has ever existed. ‘Occupied’ by Egypt and Jordan at the time, the land fell into Israeli hands during the 1967 Six Day War. Once established, however, the lie allowed ‘Israeli occupation’ to be exploited as the cause of all Palestinian misery, as well as the justification for all Palestinian violence.
With unrelenting criticism of Israel and a bag full of journalistic tricks that has lasted to this day—misleading headlines, selected film footage, biased reporting, etc.—the media helped Yasser Arafat turn the tables on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, making villain of the victim and victim of the terrorist—yet another lesson well learned by his successors, who blame 9/11 on the United States because of its support for Israel.
Then, stopping the terror became Israel’s burden instead of Arafat’s obligation. As a result, the Jewish state became the only nation in the world to be encouraged to negotiate with terrorists, condemned for retaliating against terrorist attacks, and polarized from the international community for refusing to jeopardize the security of its people.
Today, disarming Hezbollah has become Israel’s burden instead of Lebanon’s obligation under UN Resolution 1559. And Israel is condemned for doing so.
Then, the news media turned its back Arafat’s systematic pollution of the Palestinian psyche through decades of educational, cultural, and religious programs designed to demonize Israel and incite hatred and violence. Generations of Palestinian children have been raised on a perverted regional history in which there were no Jews, promised a future Palestine in which there will be no Jews, and taught to believe that they are divinely entitled to nothing less.
Moreover, the media allowed the fabricated portrayal of a menacing Jewish state to obscure the fact that the Palestinians actually flourished under thirty years of Israeli rule. Dramatic economic growth; vastly improved health, education, and social services; significantly lower illiteracy and mortality rates; the establishment of numerous institutions of higher learning—all occurred during and because of ‘Israeli occupation.’
Today, children throughout the Muslim world are being taught a similar curriculum that demonizes Israel and the United States, and Palestinians are still without a ‘state’ of their own.
Then, Yasser Arafat broke every peace treaty he ever signed. With good reason. For him,
the ‘Palestinian Problem’ was never about the Palestinians, just as ‘Israeli occupation’ was never about ‘occupied territories.’ It was about liberating Palestine—all of Palestine.
Today, nothing has changed. The Palestinians continue to suffer under the rule of terrorists who, like Arafat, will never settle for anything less than the total destruction of the Jewish state. Israel continues to defend itself by any means necessary. And the news media continues to play the proactive role it adopted when Yasser Arafat began his journey to the Nobel Peace Prize in a trail of blood.

Posted by: Joel Block | Aug 20 2006 5:38 utc | 11

I think you might be lost posting here. The only outrage is against you wasting valuable electrons with your worthless post. The only thing I find funny in your pack of lies is your fixation with Arafat. Dude, get with the program. You are about three official enemies behind the pack. Were you late for the last two munute hate, or what?

Posted by: Malooga | Aug 20 2006 5:55 utc | 12

Debs, we found our way to Good Karma out past Chandi Dasa, and next door to a aboriginal fishing village. One morning I was up early and they took me out, before dawn, dugout outriggers with patched batik sails pushing en masse in a great flotilla out into the blue-water Straits until we were sailing right by the super-tankers, like butterflies in front of semi-trailers.
Later that afternoon, trying to decide what “karma” that experience had for me, I caught a glimpse of a native guy boning a native girl on a bamboo mat up against the cinder block wall separating the hotel lanai from the backcountry swamp the hotel dumped its sewage into. So much for ‘meaning’.
Our favorite experience was the shadow puppets in Ubud. We were there for a once-every-few-years mass cremation and gamalon festival, going crazy with heat and pounding gongs, and ended up in some back alley, listening to these ancient Indonesian puppetmasters cackling (in English!) as they did a non-traditional puppet play about Bill Clinton boning Monica Lewinski, and it was so damn funny, the way they made the Clinton doll moan and jiggle his hips, “Oh, Monica-a-a-a!”
Appropo of nothing Neo, Bali is. Appropo of nothing haolie.

Posted by: Harley Freeburn | Aug 20 2006 6:00 utc | 13