Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
August 21, 2006
“Revolutionary” and “Scarcity”

by citizen
(lifted from a comment)

At LeSpeakeasy, b real brought up for question Bookchin’s use of the terms "revolutionary" and "scarcity". I answered there, and will cross post here:

About scarcity:

I took Bookchin to mean something like what Malooga referred to the other day with the story of yeast in a culture – Two outcomes, either the yeast run out of sugar and die off for starvation (scarcity) or they don’t run out of sugar but do end up awash in a wealth of toxins that also kill off the culture (post-scarcity). Malooga I thought was citing a kind of nightmare, and I think it is the one that Bookchin could see coming all too well.

About revolutionary:

I dislike this term for a couple reasons, but for the main problem is
that it seems to be begging for arrest. I imagine Bookchin chose it
because he wanted to be absolutely clear about the conservatism of most
so-called revolutionaries, because he wanted to declare that the
capitalist rules/game serves humanity 0%, and therefore must eventually
betray us all, and so with such an opposition there can be no
accommodation, only opposition. The game MUST be changed.

But since I see no need to discredit myself as a proponent of humane
society, and because I agree with you that revolution is imagined by
most readers in a reactionary imagery, I would prefer a term more like
“communalist,” and so did Bookchin in the end.

But I wanted to start with “Listen, Marxixt!” because so many at MOA
clearly identify with the left, and I want to discuss what it means to
identify and ‘steer’ left. I am grateful to Bookchin for putting so
clearly that “appearing” left is a disaster. For Bookchin, nothing was
to be idolized, and especially not ones politics. Politics are to be
worked out in dialog, and that can never be done honestly when one
wants to appear to know all the answers.

A question now being addressed at MOA: do we identify with
particular anti-imperialists simply because they fight imperialism? If
we fail to make such solidarity, do we make ourselves tools of the
capitalist game/rules? My guess is that Bookchin’s take on fashionable
Marxians offers some guidance:

Let us contrast two approaches, the
Marxian and the revolutionary. The Marxian doctrinaire would have us
approach the worker–or better, "enter" the factory–and proselytize
him in "preference" to anyone else. The purpose?–to make the worker
"class conscious." To cite the most neanderthal examples from the old
left, one cuts one’s hair, grooms oneself in conventional sports
clothing, abandons pot for cigarettes and beer, dances conventionally,
affects "rough" mannerisms, and develops a humorless, deadpan and
pompous mien.

One becomes, in short, what the worker at his most caricaturized
worst: not a "petty bourgeois degenerate," to be sure, but a bourgeois
degenerate. One becomes an imitation of the worker insofar as the
worker is an imitation of his masters. Beneath the metamorphosis of the
student into the "worker" lies a vicious cynicism. One tries to use the
discipline inculcated by the factory milieu to discipline the worker to
the party milieu. One tries to use the worker’s respect for the
industrial hierarchy to wed to worker to the party hierarchy. This
disgusting process, which if successful could lead only to the
substitution of one hierarchy for another, is achieved by pretending to
be concerned with the worker’s economic day-to-day demands. (Listen, Marxist!)

The last line here is tough on us – it demands that we stop fooling
ourselves, and choose real strengths rather than make believe ones.
Bookchin seems to demand that we not pretend to care about people whom
we know nothing about, Rather, if we are honest, we will forthrightly
state that we do not know Hassan Nasrallah, and that any opposition we
have to anti-freedom imperial politics is based on very local intimate
knowledge that we actually can speak to authoritatively. Any sympathy
we might have for someone fighting empire in Lebanon is speculative.

However, it is not speculative to say, we are against babies
screaming pitifully for milk because an American made bomb has
destroyed the baby’s mother. We can speak as authorities on babies
crying because we have heard them and knew that the one thing for the
hungry baby is its mothers breasts – living breasts preferably. And no
armament profit will excuse that murder, that double murder. And of
course the armament profit will not even bother to excuse such murders,
but will simply sweep them aside. That is reason enough, reasons we
understand, to oppose the bombing.

We can speak as authorities on the evil of murdering mothers by
bombing them in their beds at night, or while cooking for their
families in the day, because we know that every child has one mother,
only one irreplaceable mother. We do not have to pretend exotic
knowledge and concerns – we already know enough about what it means to
be a Lebanese human being, because we know what it means to be a human
being.

We have our own ‘bombed-out’ city of New Orleans, and know the human
need in a capitalized society for assistance from the government. We
know that Cuba prevented casualties from hurricanes. And we know that
Lebanese displaced people are being housed without being imprisoned,
that HB is already rebuilding houses. What is the US and Louisiana
state record in like matters? I support the people who actually build
communities. My sense is that Bookchin is saying to first revolutionize
the hearts around you, and demand to have a say in how your community
plans and directs itself. Then, as a community, decide which other
communities to support. My sense is that the Bookchin answer for most
is to build community assemblies, and lobby to have them support other
communities in the world.

This seems more demanding to me, and so perhaps revolutionary
because it would demand that we first revolutionize oneselves. Rather
than talking first about whom we support, better we should work to
understand the point of working to create local assemblies, then
actually create general support for local assemblies, then to create
actual local assemblies, THEN to work to get that popular assembly to
speak in the voice of popular sovereignty, and it could say – “stop
bombing mothers.”

That’s revolutionary.

Comments

though, I think habermas’s morality in communicative action is decisive for the justification of noncoersive interaction crucial to social integration and cultural reproduction. but bookchin’s take on nonhierarchy is an unconvincing vindication of anarchism and has little political saliency, even less than your evidently jejune marxisms, ck.

Posted by: slothrop | Aug 28 2006 2:33 utc | 101

i’m referring to bookchin’s basic arg in the ecology opus, not the little article linked to by citizen.
even old women’s quilting bees turn into vicious political struggles. so what? what doesn’t? such problems don’t stop the old women from creating beautiful quilts.

Posted by: slothrop | Aug 28 2006 2:40 utc | 102

@Sloth:
The rain in Spain falls most jejunely and intemperately on the plain.
Piss on my head, and tell me it’s raining.
Check out the honeypots way upthread and you’ll see they are overflowing.
Anybody got any kimchi?
I’m hungry.

Posted by: Ms Manners | Aug 28 2006 2:44 utc | 103

Sloth you are mixing up several things. In “Listen Marxist” one of the topics is the observed action of “marxist” parties and “marxists” on popular movements. Whether to you these are “jejune” or inauthentic manifestations of the inner spiritual meaning of “marxism” has as little relevance as the protestations of an Episcopalean that the Dominianists are not “real” christians. Bookchin’s claim is that “marxists” have a negative effect on popular movements. By “marxist” he does not mean “academics whose writings meet Slothrop’s test of marxist thinking”. That’s Bookchin’s preliminary argument. Bookchin also takes issue with the marxist claim to stand outside value systems – a claim that I believe is akin to the contemporary attempts of German mathematicians to find a pure axiomatic basis for mathematical reasoning. What marx conflates is analysis and purpose. We may use class as _part_ of an analysis to understand how things are working, but that does not mean we can derive from class analysis any moral preference for stalin over pinochet over Bush over the hippie commune of Burlington unless we accept, by faith, the absurd claim that history generates the class consciousness and mission of the proletariat. The entire rickety structure of marxist teleology is an attempt to circumvent the external (although not independent) nature of morality. And note the “not independent”. The morality of Pericles has a appeal that is external to history, but Pericles moral thinking was certainly constrained by his historical circumstances, class, gender, and language. Bookchin exposes the moral assumptions of capitalism that are embedded within Marxs thought and argues for an alternative – not completely persuasively as far as I am concerned.

Posted by: citizen k | Aug 28 2006 2:51 utc | 104

bookchin condemns all hierarchy, marxist or no. this philosophy would exclude malooga’s social movement of the month club.

Posted by: slothrop | Aug 28 2006 3:51 utc | 105

@Sloth:
Malooga has some knowledge of the world.
Would give you a compass, but doubt you could find your way out of an enclosed sheep pen 3km x 3km, if you really knew how the device worked.
Would have to drop you dog kibble and such in there, for six months, before you quite figured it out, just to keep you alive.
My guess.

Posted by: Ms Manners | Aug 28 2006 5:37 utc | 106

and I suspect you’re a drunk, mrs manners.

Posted by: slothrop | Aug 28 2006 15:09 utc | 107

nobody by this point accepts marx’s hegelian “teleology.” ck, you are a master of the strawman argument.
there’s also not very much in marx which is normative. workers of the world, organize. that’s about it. and none of this has anything to do w/ morality per se.
the only point you touch on left w/ some relevance is the problem of power, of reification. the end of class conflict and commodification will solve this problem? but, there are intermediate steps needed to be taken in order for this to be so–a fact bookchin denies because he never liked to take orders from the central committee.

Posted by: slothrop | Aug 28 2006 15:19 utc | 108

also, I’m not really dogging malooga too much here. the debate about radical localism and the “prolixity” of viewpoints made possible by new media has inspired utopianism which declaims much of marx and the need for centralized political institutions in favor of diffuse interactions responding to local, quotidian interests and problems. in this utopianism too, we find a happy conjunction of postmodernist politics w/ a moral marx. i would characterize the “autonoma” marxism of negri and others w/ this view–very close to bookchin. for an excellent hiustory of these various “movements,” read dyer-witherford’s cyber-marx, and the collection nof essays in marxism after marxism.
I think, given the realities of globalism, these autonomous constructions of opposition against capital, accomplished often without the direct knowledge of agents(!), is so much wishful thinking by “agents” who can afford the new blackberry.

Posted by: slothrop | Aug 28 2006 15:40 utc | 109

Logic: Not Optional
Slothrop(17) has cited a need for strong global institutions of social security and succor, and simultaneously accused educatory politics such as Bookchins of being bourgeois, by which I gather that these approaches seem to him based on air, impossible to carry out in the real world. Fair enough, it is possible that these approaches may be nothing more than exercises designed to continue the work of working for a just politics. It might be that they will fail to create an entirely new world. But imperfection may not be a flaw here, but instead a mark that this is the best thing possible now.
Honestly, slothrop, I was shocked by your response. I thought that you of all people would appreciate that the commodity form is not merely a social and economic practice, but that it is the very core logic of capitalism. It channels thought. And no revolution is possible without thinking differently, yet you seem to skirt this need to think more critically. Our critique of CAP logic is precisely based on grasping that a logic which understands and reasons about things more and more in terms of their exchange value and less and less in terms of their use value will inevitably make the world useless, a mess, a toxic cesspool. Marx grasped this in terms of the immiseration of long hours, physical hardship on the laborers, and miserable living standards. Bookchin points out that this has not come to pass, and that it is far more likely for us to re-appraise the importance of use value when it smacks us in the face every day as a dying planet and our suffering bodies. How is it that you can ignore the seriousness of this analysis? Something that you may be buffering out of awareness is that Marx himself posited the possibility of revolution in terms of the consciousness of proletariat workers. I mention the commodity form to point to the one chink in the armor of capitalist society against individuals’ critical awareness that something stinks – and this chink is precisely the minds of individuals. So why poo-pooh the possibility of revolutuionary change that springs from human consciousness?
What if the propaganda industry can and will continue to consistently fragment class consciousness, now and in the future? Marx may have been wrong about the factory as a nursery of revolution. But as Bookchin points out, what if the entire planet has become a factory, and planetary immiseration is doing what factory immiseration could not? What if globalism and nationalism cannot fool us into thinking there is another planet we can escape to? If so, then Bookchin may be a legitimate political theorist of actually possible change that can be accomplished by individuals. . . changing their minds.
For social activists looking to change the world, the apparent problem with Marxism is that it is a critical theory of capitalism, not a practical manual for revolution. It seems designed to know CAP, not to change it. Critical knowledge of CAP tends to analyze at the social level, and so the agents of action are all social, not individual. However, the commodity form is Marx’s first chapter for good reasons, and one of those good reasons is that it registers a weakness in these social actions that proceed almost entirely above the heads of us poor slobs, the individuals – and that weakness is that social action depends on individuals accepting the logic of the commodity form. We individuals must accept and reason by this logic in order for CAP to proceed and work to run everything else. Marx marks the commodity form as the logic by which social and individual agents of capital control social evolution. As a result, strong global institutions of social security and succor no matter how well intentioned will always transform to follow capitalist logics of social action until and unless we change the way we think.
So, to pooh pooh thought as a bourgeois focus for activism is to pooh pooh the sheer possibility of ever overcoming social dominance over individual actions.
First, do no harm.
Let’s not counsel activists to despair. I agree entirely that people cannot simply choose to think differently, that changing the way we think is based in social processes. However, Bookchin has met this challenge, has mounted a serious proposal – one entirely consonant with Marx’s critique of CAP – a proposal that people’s experience can and will change via the experience of planetary immiseration. We are not simply choosing, we are opening our eyes to our experience.
And awareness of a different logic is not bourgeois.

Posted by: citizen | Aug 29 2006 14:30 utc | 110

Logic: Not Optional
Slothrop(17) has cited a need for strong global institutions of social security and succor, and simultaneously accused educatory politics such as Bookchins of being bourgeois, by which I gather that these approaches seem to him based on air, impossible to carry out in the real world. Fair enough, it is possible that these approaches may be nothing more than exercises designed to continue the work of working for a just politics. It might be that they will fail to create an entirely new world. But imperfection may not be a flaw here, but instead a mark that this is the best thing possible now.
Honestly, slothrop, I was shocked by your response. I thought that you of all people would appreciate that the commodity form is not merely a social and economic practice, but that it is the very core logic of capitalism. It channels thought. And no revolution is possible without thinking differently, yet you seem to skirt this need to think more critically.
Marx critiqued a dialectic of use value and exchange value
Our critique of CAP logic is precisely based on grasping that a logic which understands and reasons about things more and more in terms of their exchange value and less and less in terms of their use value will inevitably make the world useless, a mess, a toxic cesspool. Marx grasped this in terms of the immiseration of long hours, physical hardship on the laborers, and miserable living standards. Bookchin points out that this has not come to pass, and that it is far more likely for us to re-appraise the importance of use value when it smacks us in the face every day as a dying planet and our suffering bodies.
How is it that you can ignore the seriousness of this analysis? Something that you may be buffering out of awareness is that Marx himself posited the possibility of revolution in terms of the consciousness of proletariat workers. I mention the commodity form to point to the one chink in the armor of capitalist society against individuals’ critical awareness that something stinks – and this chink is precisely the minds of individuals. So why poo-pooh the possibility of revolutuionary change that springs from human consciousness?
What if the propaganda industry can and will continue to consistently fragment class consciousness, now and in the future? Marx may have been wrong about the factory as a nursery of revolution. But as Bookchin points out, what if the entire planet has become a factory, and planetary immiseration is doing what factory immiseration could not? What if globalism and nationalism cannot fool us into thinking there is another planet we can escape to? If so, then Bookchin may be a legitimate political theorist of actually possible change that can be accomplished by individuals. . . changing their minds.
For social activists looking to change the world, the apparent problem with Marxism is that it is a critical theory of capitalism, not a practical manual for revolution. It seems designed to know CAP, not to change it. Critical knowledge of CAP tends to analyze at the social level, and so the agents of action are all social, not individual. However, the commodity form is Marx’s first chapter for good reasons, and one of those good reasons is that it registers a practical weakness in these social actions that proceed almost entirely above the heads of us poor slobs, the individuals – and that weakness is that social action depends on individuals accepting the logic of the commodity form. We individuals must accept and reason by this logic in order for CAP to proceed and work to run everything else. Marx marks the commodity form as the logic by which social and individual agents of capital control social evolution. As a result, strong global institutions of social security and succor no matter how well intentioned will always transform to follow capitalist logics of social action until and unless we change the way we think.
Can activists choose their logic? No, but. . .
So, to pooh pooh thought as a bourgeois focus for activism is to pooh pooh the sheer possibility of ever overcoming social dominance over individual actions.
First, do no harm.
Let’s not counsel activists to despair. I agree entirely that people cannot simply choose to think differently, that changing the way we think is based in social processes. However, Bookchin has met this challenge, has mounted a serious proposal – one entirely consonant with Marx’s critique of CAP – a proposal that people’s experience can and will change via the experience of planetary immiseration. We are not simply choosing, we are opening our eyes to our experience.
And awareness of a different logic is not bourgeois.

Posted by: citizen | Aug 29 2006 14:48 utc | 111

citizen
what you describe there it seems is the problem of thought reified in the commodity form, i.e., false-consciousness, which is objectively real. that is, it really is true that people are reified and commodities are personified. this hegemony of the commodity forn is the mode of production’s justification. overcoming this catastrophe can only be accomplished by transforming the mode of production. no easy task.
in a work of almost 200,000 words, bookchin in his opus never discussess the fetish of the commodities. why? it’s because the rejection of marx by bookchin requires rejection of the mastery of “nature” via a mode of production in the delivery of ever expanding needs. in place of this:

The modern world has abandoned this notion and reduced reason to rationalization, that is, to, mere technique for achieving practical ends. Logos, in effect, was simply turned into logic. This book tries to recover this notion of an immanent world reason, albeit without the archaic, quasi-theological trappings [11] that render this notion untenable to a more knowledgeable and secular society. In my view, reason exists in nature as the self-organizing attributes of substance; it is the latent subjectivity in the inorganic and organic levels of reality that reveal an inherent striving toward consciousness.

i read this, and i can’t emphasize too much how it reminds me of dewey. in any case, for bookchin, the mode of production separating “first nature” from humanity results in reified consciousness, if you want to call it by this name. and no lifting the scales from workers’ eyes to deploy productive domination of nature will change this outcome. so, for bnookchin, it’s “libertarian municipalism”–the local, autarkic management of reproduction oriented to sustainability–the resurrection of harmonious humanity with nature.
kumbaya.
life is mode of production. language already seperates us from “1st nature.” there is no unity of structure/agency. where there is, you’ll not find any humans there.
we can only inherit the developmnent of productive forces to deliver globally the resources needed to improve equity and sustainability. we need institutions and gatekeeping to do that. bookchin will just have to do what he’s told, in order to be happy.

Posted by: slothrop | Aug 29 2006 15:28 utc | 112

bookchin will just have to do what he’s told, in order to be happy.
Who will tell the tellers what to tell us?

Posted by: citizen | Aug 29 2006 16:01 utc | 113

we can only inherit the developmnent of productive forces to deliver globally the resources needed to improve equity and sustainability
these modern concepts of “development” and “production” are entirely antithetical to “equity” and “sustainability”. production & development are the conversion of the living to the dead. doesn’t matter who is in charge of the means of this conversion – it still requires/destroys resources.

Posted by: b real | Aug 29 2006 16:42 utc | 114

if these definitions are to change, it most definitely will require new ways of thinking/understanding/acting

Posted by: b real | Aug 29 2006 16:48 utc | 115

production & development are the conversion of the living to the dead. doesn’t matter who is in charge of the means of this conversion – it still requires/destroys resources.
so it goes.

Posted by: slothrop | Aug 29 2006 17:02 utc | 116

Okay, its the guys in the white hats. Damn, why didn’t I think of that?

Posted by: citizen | Aug 29 2006 17:26 utc | 117

I’m working up another post to start a new Bookchin thread, and I thought I should clear up a loose thread, something careless on my part. I attributed an analogy about yeast to Malooga, but I actually owe that to Monolycus. Here is the full version, and very suggestive for our conversation:

More than simply being against a particular war, I am seeing some incredibly large problems on the landscape . . . Are you familiar with yeast?  Yeast in a petri dish have only one of two options.  Normally, in order to culture yeast, one has to introduce sugar as a food source.  The yeast will continue to grow in the petri dish until they have consumed all the sugar… at which point they starve and the yeast colony dies.  One can add sugar, however, to prevent this.  A colony of yeast in a petri dish with a limitless supply of sugar will continue to grow, but they also produce waste (carbon dioxide and alcohol, chiefly).  Eventually, the colony will be swimming in its own waste until it chokes itself to death.  Those are the only two outcomes that a colony of yeast in a closed system can look forward to.  Scientists have long been aware of this and their only response has been to cryptically observe that “humans are not yeast”. 

Posted by: citizen | Aug 29 2006 17:33 utc | 118

Who will tell the tellers what to tell us?
me

Posted by: slothrop | Aug 29 2006 19:23 utc | 119

Sloth: Marxism, in its current form, is curious exercise of a few academics writing for an audience of themselves about the overthrow a global system by an imaginary mass movement. The production of “revolutionary rhetoric” has itself been rationalized, organized, and tamed as the marxist professors do their part for the GDP – transforming bullshit into salaries. Bookchin, looking at the transformation of socialism from a political movement of workers into a front for the Soviet state and then into the European Union Against Populism, a handful of jargon spouting schismatics, and another handful of jargon spouting academics – both without audiences – looks for a way out.

Posted by: citizen k | Aug 30 2006 12:58 utc | 120

really, at this moment, marxism and not anarchism, is more “relevant.”
if you want to find bullshit turned into paychecks, visit the economics and sociology departments.

Posted by: slothrop | Aug 30 2006 15:05 utc | 121

really, at this moment, marxism and not anarchism, is more “relevant.”
well, this issue is, as i understand it, the central focus for citizen’s selection of bookchin’s pamphlet. bookchin was advocating looking not so much to the past as to the future. slothrop has carefully phrased his belief that marxism is more relevant “at this moment”. but what promise of a sustainable future does it hold? discarding marx’s antiquated historical materialism which held that societies must “progress” through a rough sequence of feudalism -> capitalism -> socialism -> communism in order to reach perfection, which i’d hope that reasonable people can see for what it was/is, what vision does marxism offer for the future? bookchin, at least, had an advantage over marx & his industrial trappings in grounding himself in a more organic, ecological outlook. whereas marx’s context was essentially euro-centric & production-oriented, bookchin has engaged a broader, humanist view of all life.

Posted by: b real | Aug 30 2006 15:48 utc | 122

which i’d hope that reasonable people can see for what it was/is, what vision does marxism offer for the future?
uh-oh. c’mon now. The wealth of bourgeois society, at first sight, presents itself as an immense accumulation of commodities, its unit being a single commodity. and we know the problem is the need to accelerate consumption while also squeezing the cost of labor. what a drag and what a remarkable waste of labor power and time.
also, to the extent something like a “dialectical history”
exists is plainly revealed by vthe development of the forces of production on a global scale. bookchin rejected marxism because the nationalist development of production in the metropolitan core accommodated very high wages, even for unskilled labor. happy prolketarians, all. but the times, they are changfing, and bookchin, based on what I have read of him, misrecognized this “movement of capital.”

Posted by: slothrop | Aug 30 2006 16:14 utc | 123

“humanism”
which “human”?

Posted by: slothrop | Aug 30 2006 16:16 utc | 124

b real
the debate over whether technology and science embody the ideology of the prevailing mode of production or whether these functions can be directed toward socialism is a thorny one. we know where bookchin comes down on this question.
my problem w/ this is the rejection of marx here requires a belief that technology in toto is ideologically capitalist. I take this to be marcuse’s or adorno’s, and in another nonideology-obseessed way, heidegger. but, habermas’s famous marcuse birthday essay explaqins why such totalizing endorsement of a kind of ted kaczynski-like hatred for tech/science is only partially correct: instrumental reason never completely dominates life.

Posted by: slothrop | Aug 30 2006 16:51 utc | 125

In rapturous words Marx eulogizes the revolutionary role of the bourgeoisie:
The bourgeoisie cannot exist without constantly revolutionizing the instruments of production, and [116] thereby the relations of production, and with them the whole relations of society.
In another passage he writes:

The bourgeoisie, during its rule of scarce one hundred years, has created more massive and more colossal productive forces than have all preceding generations together. Subjection of nature’s forces to man, machinery, application of chemistry to industry and agriculture, steam navigation, railways, electric telegraphs, clearing of whole continents for cultivation, canalization of rivers, whole populations conjured out of the ground . . .

Marx also perceives the reaction of this development back upon the institutional framework:

All fixed, fast-frozen relations, with their train of ancient and venerable prejudices and opinions, are swept away, all new-formed ones become antiquated before they can ossify. All that is solid melts into air, all that is holy is profaned, and man is at last compelled to face with sober senses his real conditions of life and his relations with his kind.

It is with regard to the disproportion between the passive adaptation of the institutional framework and the “active subjection of nature” that the assertion that men make their history, but not with ‘will or consciousness, was formulated. It was the aim of Marx’s critique to transform the secondary adaptation of the institutional framework as well into an active one, and to bring under control the structural change of society itself. This would overcome a fundamental condition of all previous history and complete the self-constitution of mankind: the end of prehistory. But this idea was ambiguous.
Marx, to be sure, viewed the problem of making history [117]with will and consciousness as one of the practical mastery of previously ungoverned processes of social development. Others, however, have understood it as a technical problem. They want to bring society under control in the same way as nature by reconstructing it according to the pattern of self-regulated systems of purposive-rational action and adaptive behavior. This intention is to be found not only among technocrats of capitalist planning but also among those of bureaucratic socialism. Only the technocratic consciousness obscures the fact that this reconstruction could be achieved at no less a cost than closing off the only dimension that is essential, because it is susceptible to humanization, as a structure of interactions mediated by ordinary language. In the future the repertoire of control techniques will be considerably expanded.
…
A prediction of this sort is extremely controversial. Nevertheless, it points to an area of future possibilities of detaching human behavior from a normative system linked to the grammar of [118]language-games and integrating it instead into self-regulated subsystems of the man-machine type by means of immediate physical or psychological control. Today the psychotechnic manipulation of behavior can already liquidate the old fashioned detour through norms that are internalized but capable of reflection. Behavioral control could be instituted at an even deeper level tomorrow through biotechnic intervention in the endocrine regulating system, not to mention the even greater consequences of intervening in the genetic transmission of inherited information. If this occurred, old regions of consciousness developed in ordinary-language communication would of necessity completely dry up. At this stage of human engineering, if the end of psychological manipulation could be spoken of in the same sense as the end of ideology is today, the spontaneous alienation derived from the uncontrolled lag of the institutional framework would be overcome. But the self-objectivation of man would have fulfilled itself in planned alienation -men would make their history with will, but without consciousness.
I am not asserting that this cybernetic dream of the instinct-like self-stabilization of societies is being fulfilled or that it is even realizable. I do think, however, that it follows through certain vague but basic assumptions of technocratic consciousness to their conclusion as a negative utopia and thus denotes an evolutionary trend that is taking shape under the slick domination of technology and science as ideology. Above all, it becomes clear against this background that two concepts o f rationalization must be distinguished. At the level of subsystems of purposive-rational action, scientific-technical progress has already compelled the reorganization of social institutions and sectors, and necessitates it on an even larger scale than heretofore. But this process of the development of the productive forces can be a potential for liberation if and only if it does not replace rationalization on another level.
Rationalization at the level of the institutional framework can occur only in the medium of symbolic interaction itself, that is, through removing restrictions on communication. Public, unrestricted discussion, free from domination, of the suitability and desirability of [119]action-orienting principles and norms in the light of the sociocultural repercussions of developing subsystems of purposiverational action-such communication at all levels of political and repoliticized decision-making processes is the only medium in which anything like “rationalization” is possible.
-Technology and Science as “Ideology”
For Herbert Marcuse on his seventieth birthday, July 19, 1968

pow.

Posted by: slothrop | Aug 30 2006 17:09 utc | 126

definitely no rejection “in toto” of marx in the conversation as i’ve read it, though necessary questions, critiques, and thoughts which foster critical evaluation in the advance of action. will spend more time revisiting bookchin’s positions on technology wrt marx’s. when i first read the freedom book i found his faith in the neutrality of technologies frustratingly naive at times.

Posted by: b real | Aug 30 2006 17:28 utc | 127

Five Theses on Activism, Two Corollaries, and 2 Bookchins
slothrop did the honorable dialogical thing and let it be known that she doesn’t think that authoritarian control by our betters (be the Right or Left) will guard us from being devoured.
So now I guess it’s my turn to be more specific about what I aim to explore through Bookchin.
So, for your consideration, 5 theses on activism that we can explore through Bookchin:
1) All modern states find themselves obligated to produce national histories that show evidence and reasoning that will prove that the state seeks the welfare of its people as a community.
2) Therefore, any modern state (this includes all contemporary states because we all live in the same time) must seek to absolve itself of blame for choosing economic/cultural losers by various means. These means may best be labelled as modern society’s Culture Faculty. A few examples: state sanctioned education, other memory holes, xenophobia and the justification of war.
3) Because the state cannot take full, public responsibility for raison d’etat or raison d’capital in their full mercilessness, nations will remain as a permanent figure of government under capitalism, and international competitions will long justify all planned failings of states. Capitalism and a world state cannot coexist because capitalist growth seeks to guarantee certain benefitees, and so requires a constantly shifting unevenness that will specify specific sets of people who will sacrifice their resources so that others can be guaranteed sucess in growing theirs. (c.f. Primitive Accumulation – modify it as a never-ending process, within the Limits of Yeast).
4) Any criticism of the state will be sufficient to label the critic as a terra-ist.
5) Humanist activism (activism that values humans above capital) will be more effective if it accepts capitalism and the state’s imbrication with the machinations of capitalism, and devotes itself to loyal opposition – along the lines of Bookchin’s libertarian municipalism.
Corollary 1: non-violence
Corollary 2: activists must work to evade capture of municipal citizen assemblies by modern society’s Culture Faculty.
Two Bookchin readings to help us constitute this discussion with a specific set of references. First, one that suggests how Bookchin offers a vision of citizen activism that both accepts state problems, and resists them:

Thus, libertarian municipalism is not merely an effort simply to “take over” city councils to construct a more “environmentally friendly” city government. These adherents–or opponents–of libertarian municipalism, in effect, look at the civic structures that exist before their eyes now and essentially (all rhetoric to the contrary aside) take them as they exist . Libertarian municipalism, by contrast, is an effort to transform and democratize city governments, to root them in popular assemblies, to knit them together along confederal lines, to appropriate a regional economy along confederal and municipal lines.
In fact, libertarian municipalism gains its life and its integrity precisely from the dialectical tension it proposes between the nation-state and the municipal confederation. Its “law of life,” to use an old Marxian term, consists precisely in its struggle with the state. The tension between municipal confederations and the state must be clear and uncompromising. Since these confederations would exist primarily in opposition to statecraft, they cannot be compromised by state, provincial, or national elections, much less achieved by these means. Libertarian municipalism is formed by its struggle with the state, strengthened by this struggle, indeed defined by this struggle. Divested of this dialectical tension with the state, libertarian municipalism becomes little more than “sewer socialism.”
Many heroic comrades who are prepared to do battle (one day) with the cosmic forces of capitalism find that libertarian municipalism is too thorny, irrelevant, or vague to deal with and opt for what is basically a form of political particularism. Our spray-can or “alternative cafe” radicals may choose to brush libertarian municipalism aside as “a ludicrous tactic,” but it never ceases to amaze me that well-meaning radicals who are committed to the “overthrow” of capitalism (no less!) find it too difficult to function politically–and, yes, electorally–in their own neighborhoods for a new politics based on a genuine democracy. If they cannot provide a transformative politics for their own neighborhood–a relatively modest task–or diligently work at doing so with the constancy that used to mark the more mature left movements of the past, I find it very hard to believe that they will ever do much harm to the present social system. Indeed, by creating cultural centers, parks, and good housing, they may well be improving the system by giving capitalism a human face without diminishing its underlying unfreedom as a hierarchical and class society.

Second, one that begins to suggests how Bookchin’s assemblies would have to resist the Culture Faculty.

Laudable as the goal of reduced consumption may seem, it is an ineffectual exercise in charity, not social mobilization; in humanitarianism, not social change. It is also an exercise in a superficial form of social analysis that grossly under plays the profoundly systemic factors that have produced overfed elites in all parts of the world and masses of underfed underlings. Nearly all we learn from Dammann’s liberal good intentions is that an ecumenical “we” must be faulted for the ills of the world-a mystical “consumer” who greedily demands goodies that “our” overworked corporations are compelled to produce.
Despite the radical rhetoric to which Devall and Sessions resort, the principal practical recipe for social change they have to offer “us” in Deep Ecology is little more than a naive prayer. “Our first principle,” they write, “is to encourage agencies, legislators, property owners and managers to consider flowing with rather than forcing natural processes.” We should “act through the political process to inform managers and government agencies of the principles of deep ecology,” to achieve “some significant changes in the direction of wise long-range management policies.”
[jump]
The ecology movement is too important to allow itself to be taken over by airy mystics and reactionary misanthropes. The traditional labor movement, on which so many radicals placed their hopes for creating a new society, has withered, and in the United States the old time populist movements have died with the agrarian strata that provided them with sizable followings. Rooseveltian liberalism’s future hangs in the balance as a result of the Reagan-Bush assault on New Deal reforms The cooptation of nearly every worthwhile cause, including conventional environmentalism itself, is symbolized by the ease with which corporations tout the slogan EVERY DAY IS EARTH DAY!

b,
I know I sent you a different draft earlier, but it had problems. Please consider this my nomination for a new threadhead.

Posted by: citizen | Aug 30 2006 17:37 utc | 128

Doh,
4) Any criticism of the state will be sufficient to label the critic as a terra-ist.
should read
4) Any effective criticism of the state by individuals lacking affiliation via sovereign citizen assemblies will be sufficient to label the critic as a terra-ist.

Posted by: citizen | Aug 30 2006 17:43 utc | 129

5 Activist Theses cross-posted at LeSpeakeasy.

Posted by: citizen | Aug 30 2006 18:01 utc | 130

today’s program at against the grain featured a speech by bookchin titled Ecology and Ideology from the 1970s. they don’t have the mp3 of the show up yet, but should be avail to listen to later. (technincal problems for the first minute or so.. in case they don’t edit that out, don’t give up)

Posted by: b real | Aug 30 2006 20:06 utc | 131

You beat me to it b real, I was waiting for them to post the audio. Excellent Bookchin speech, it won me over, as I had unexplainable reservations. I highly recon this talk.
Did you also listen to the Guns and Butter show today?
The NORAD Audio Tapes: Real or Faked?
http://www.gunsandbutter.net/

Interview with Dr. David Ray Griffin regarding his most recent article, “9/11 Live or Fabricated: Do the NORAD Tapes Verify the 9/11 Commission Report?” Griffin’s article, written primarily in response to Vanity Fair Magazine’s, “9/11 Live: The NORAD Tapes” by Michael Bronner in their September 2006 issue, deconstructs the preposterous argument that NORAD was not notified by the FAA of hijacked airliners until they had struck their targets or crashed, and that the only jets the military scrambled were in response to a flight that did not exist. Griffin takes a close look at NORAD’s audio tapes, on whose authenticity these claims depend.

Posted by: Uncle $cam | Aug 30 2006 20:27 utc | 132

Also at the against the grain website MOA’s might be interested in: Brecht 50 Years On (mp3) This week marks the fiftieth anniversary of the death of Bertolt Brecht, the twentieth century’s most important dramatist. Brecht revolutionized the theatre by challenging audiences to move from individual passivity to critical self-reflection and collective action. A Pacifica documentary narrates Brecht’s confrontation with HUAC, while Brecht scholars Eric Bentley and Bluma Goldstein illuminate the contours of his life and work.

Posted by: Uncle $cam | Aug 30 2006 21:02 utc | 133

if you want to find bullshit turned into paychecks, visit the economics and sociology departments.
Hey, like, you see there was this German dude, man, and he said like the ideas and shit of people were kinda I dunno, affected by like how they got, you know, money, and so he wouldn’t be too blown away if it turned out that most people, cause like he wasn’t into making it too simple, most people in a factory for turning bullshit into money, thought bullshit was cool. Even if, get this, even if, they said that they were against bullshit and for, like “global revolution” or some other shit.

Posted by: citizen k | Aug 31 2006 2:24 utc | 134

Rationalization at the level of the institutional framework can occur only in the medium of symbolic interaction itself, that is, through removing restrictions on communication. Public, unrestricted discussion, free from domination, of the suitability and desirability of [119]action-orienting principles and norms in the light of the sociocultural repercussions of developing subsystems of purposiverational action-such communication at all levels of political and repoliticized decision-making processes is the only medium in which anything like “rationalization” is possible.

This is good for translation. Really like that “purposiverational action-such” stuff. German Academia!
How about: “To make fix government and economy, people need to be able to talk freely and openly. without interference from the suits about what we should do. Decisions about
economy and technology can’t be left to “experts”, but must be made as political decisions in the
old sense of politics which is how communities decide what is important. This type of discussion
is the only way in which anything serious can be changed”
– Hey, it’s an argument for net neutrality.

Posted by: Anonymous | Aug 31 2006 2:38 utc | 135

citizen k (134),
You had me at hello. : )
Look, I know this is greedy and all, but can you do Derrida, too?

Posted by: citizen | Aug 31 2006 12:50 utc | 136

citizen: I don’t drink enough anymore to be able to handle that.
thanks

Posted by: citizen k | Aug 31 2006 17:45 utc | 137

Looking back over the thread, I’m pleased to see that we seem to have a provisional consensus that no matter how global, systematic and powerful the problems of state sanctioned economic, cultural, and physical violence may be in the world, no one is seriously proposing that classical vanguardist hierarchies can actually solve the problem. The opening 30 posts or so seemed to frame the rest of our discussion:
Citizen k #19 –

One problem with the “left” is that it has not accommodated to a world in which wars can be sold like automobiles and consent can be manufactured using sophisticated techniques undreampt of in 19th century middle class German society.

Malooga #20 –

Guerrilla tactics — choosing how, when, and where to confront the leviathan on our own terms, is a viable partial solution. It sure beats joining them, and saving up for that brand new banana yellow hummer!

Gylangirl #27 makes this challenge that seems supportive of Bookchin’s flat networking –

Recipe for revolution failure: petty dismissal of disgruntled potential allies living behind enemy lines. The capitalists are winning because they actively infiltrate and turn the workers against each other. Meanwhile the revolutionary workers refuse to infiltrate the capitalist camp.

Slothrop#32 replied very accessibly:

gylangirl
basic bookchin riff is the end of “hierarchy” and “reification”–you know, no more longing for truth and essence guided by our betters.
he rejected marxism because he found the movement littered w/ “hierarchy.” he adopted instead a kind of libertarian communism based on local governance and economic autarky.
i am skeptical of his anarchism because of what i have so far found in his interesting writings a persistent lack of contact with globalism

Just before that, though, Malooga #30 had cited Bookchin’s What is Communalism, in which Bookchin specifically comes out against consensus based decision-making processes because he says they tend to demoralize popular commitment. Now, I failed to note this at the time, but citizen k #4‘s excellent David Graebner piece from the New Left Review seems to oppose or modify Bookchin here. This difference may stem from the exact problem cited by slothrop, but in accordance with slothrop’s demand, Graebner’s approach specifically cites consensus mechanisms done not on Western models but on Third World models, specifically ones with Zapatista roots. And Graebner regards these as effective in a way that overcomes citizen #19’s concerns for the reactionary effects of well propagandized wars:

If this is right, it becomes clearer what the ultimate stakes of the current eanti-terroristf mobilization are. In the short run, things do look very frightening. Governments who were desperately scrambling for some way to convince the public we were terrorists even before September 11 now feel theyfve been given carte blanche ; there is little doubt that a lot of good people are about to suffer terrible repression. But in the long run, a return to twentieth-century levels of violence is simply impossible. The September 11 attacks were clearly something of a fluke (the first wildly ambitious terrorist scheme in history that actually worked); the spread of nuclear weapons is ensuring that larger and larger portions of the globe will be for all practical purposes off-limits to conventional warfare. And if war is the health of the state, the prospects for anarchist-style organizing can only be improving.
Practising direct democracy
A constant complaint about the globalization movement in the progressive press is that, while tactically brilliant, it lacks any central theme or coherent ideology. (This seems to be the left equivalent of the corporate mediafs claims that we are a bunch of dumb kids touting a bundle of completely unrelated causes\free Mumia, dump the debt, save the old-growth forests.) Another line of attack is that the movement is plagued by a generic opposition to all forms of structure or organization. Itfs distressing that, two years after Seattle, I should have to write this, but someone obviously should: in North America especially, this is a movement about reinventing democracy. It is not opposed to organization. It is about creating new forms of organization. It is not lacking in ideology. Those new forms of organization are its ideology. It is about creating and enacting horizontal networks instead of top-down structures like states, parties or corporations; networks based on principles of decentralized, non-hierarchical consensus democracy. Ultimately, it aspires to be much more than that, because ultimately it aspires to reinvent daily life as whole. But unlike many other forms of radicalism, it has first organized itself in the political sphere\mainly because this was a territory that the powers that be (who have shifted all their heavy artillery into the economic) have largely abandoned.
Over the past decade, activists in North America have been putting enormous creative energy into reinventing their groups’ own internal processes, to create viable models of what functioning direct democracy could actually look like. In this we’ve drawn particularly, as I’ve noted, on examples from outside the Western tradition, which almost invariably rely on some process of consensus finding, rather than majority vote.

Now, since slothrop eventually did come clean that proletarian dictatorship was not acceptable in this discourse (even for slothrop) can we say that there is actually some enthusiasm here for the practical possibilities of anarchist organizing along the lines of Bookchin, or perhaps more specifically along the lines described by Graebner?
I confess finding Graebner’s version a more likely pathway towards actually achieving citizen assemblies in the first place.

Posted by: citizen | Aug 31 2006 22:09 utc | 138

a green offers “five proposals for leftists” in Notes on the Ecological Dimension

Posted by: b real | Sep 1 2006 14:46 utc | 139