Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
December 2, 2004
More good news from France

The French Socilalists have voten convincingly in favor of the EU Constitution in an internal referendum.

The man leading the "no" campaign within the party, former prime minister and now deputy party leader Laurent Fabius, has accepted defeat.

He had tried to rally supporters by saying he loved Europe too much to let France sign up to a bad treaty.

For him, the European Constitution is too Anglo-Saxon, too much about free markets and competition, too little about workers’ rights or full employment, our correspondent says.

But others in the French Socialist Party opposed his campaign.

Socialist leader Francois Hollande agreed the constitution was not perfect, but said a "no" for the party and the country that helped build Europe would be catastrophic.

This internal referendum was called after Fabius called for a "no" vote in the national referendum on the Constitution, due some time in 2005, that will authorise or not the ratification by France of the treaty. Apart from internal politicking (Fabius probably saw this as a last ditch effort to exist in a party where he has been slowly marginalised, by jumping on a hot issue) and the reluctance of some Socialists to vote yet again alongside Chirac after the humiliating 2002 election, the real possibility that the Socialists would vote against ratification is a testimony to France’s lost bearings and (unwarranted) lack of confidence in its influence on the European stage.

So this unexpectedly strong showing for the Yes is reinvigorating. It comes in that most legitimate way, after a real, serious, open,  political debate, it improves the chances of France ratifying the Constitution (and thus avoiding a real crisis of confidence in Europe at a time when a functional Europe is more needed than ever), and it acknowledges that Europe’s constitution is neither "socialist" nor "liberal" (as each side likes to fear), but a way to describe how decisions are taken together on an expanding swathe of topics of common interests, and it shows that France is not completely hopeless!

So 3 cheers today for French Socialists!

Comments

I´ll not join those cheers. That “constitution” is much too long (250 pages!), much too complicate and leaves too little control to the people. It isn´t even Democratic (one person one vote?). It should be ditched and replaced by some 3 page paper that guarantees human rights (in a European sence) and the boarder of issues decided by the EU and by the nation states. Army control belongs to the people not to head of states ….

Posted by: Anonymous | Dec 2 2004 7:39 utc | 1

Thanks to the previous poster for linking to the
document, which should be interesting reading.
I tend to agree with the criticisms expressed. The U.S.
Bill of Rights is a good model, although apparently currently out of favor in the U.S., except for the un-European second amendment which remains a cornerstone of Bushian polity.

Posted by: Hannah K. O’Luthon | Dec 2 2004 8:22 utc | 2

Yes, the constitution is long, but worth reading through. Considering that it has been hammered out by 25 countries spanning thousands of miles and thousands of years of shared history it’s pretty bloody good. There are things to criticise in it, to be sure, but everyone will choose different things, and I’m afraid that you can’t just create Utopia by fiat, you have to build it, one step at a time.
This is what we have. It’s pretty good. The trick is to get this through, then start work on getting what’s in it into practice everywhere.

Posted by: Colman | Dec 2 2004 8:36 utc | 3

In the globalony vien, I ran into to an article last night. Everyone may like to read it. After I read the article I do agree for years one family has had to much control.
Go to: http://www.nexusmagazine.com/article/rockefeller. The article is six pages.
Its a real eye opener. Maybe the conspiracy theorist aren’t all that nuts?

Posted by: jdp | Dec 2 2004 12:41 utc | 4

Rockefeller link

Posted by: Anonymous | Dec 2 2004 14:19 utc | 5

Good news for Halliburton
Halliburton wins MoD vote for £4bn Royal Navy deal

Posted by: Cloned Poster | Dec 2 2004 16:08 utc | 6

Does Fabius have any real credibility? Or a confident constituency? I rather thought he’d been done in by the “bad blood” affair of ten years ago, but apparently not…..

Posted by: alabama | Dec 2 2004 19:20 utc | 7

I’m glad to hear there are still some sane people left in the world.

Posted by: fourlegsgood | Dec 5 2004 5:11 utc | 8